'Abject... shocking at times' - Ire mixed with relief as Munster's Van Graan era ends
Any hope that Johann van Graan might have been holding to that he could end his thoroughly mediocre rein as Munster head coach on high were rudely ripped from his grasp on a balmy evening in Belfast.
Munster put in the most un-Munster-like of performances at Ravenhill, offering very little of the fight that has traditionally characterized the province. When Springbok centre Damian De Allende fumbled a ball halfway through a second half in which the men in red were chasing a scoreboard, the referee might as well have blown it up right there.
This was not Munster's evening. It never was.
Against that, a razor-sharp Ulster were well worth their 36-17 victory, a result that has seen them through to the semi-finals. But one couldn't help but feel this current Munster iteration is well off the pace.
The online reaction has been one of initial shock at the nature of the performance, a response tempered by a significant amount of relief that the Van Graan era had come to an end, even if on a bum note.
"Ulster very good, Munster not so much," wrote Brian O'Driscoll on Twitter. "A lot of work is needed in Munster’s re build - in the coming season(s) but Ulster seem very much on the right path. A bit to go yet but vastly improved on the past few years. Some international selections this summer will be interesting!"
"Munster are being completely dominated by Ulster, you won’t see a more abject performance from the men in red, shocking at times," wrote former England flyhalf and RugbyPass columnist Andy Goode.
Writing in his Irish Times report, Gerry Thornley bemoaned the inaccuracy of the Van Graan's charges: "A lamentable Munster performance, riddled with handling inaccuracies and ill-discipline as well as a defence which again bunched up narrowly too often, ended their uneven and anticlimactic season and also the Johann van Graan/Stephen Larkham/JP Ferreira era."
Popular Munster fan account, Overthehillprop summed it up well, writing: "If nothing else I'm glad this Munster era is over. They have regressed even further this year and JVGs tenure will be remembered for creating apathy within the fanbase. As for Munsters [sic] attack.... well best of luck to the Brumbies."
"The season ends with a whimper," wrote Munster blogger Three Red Kings. "Munster were sloppy, got key selection calls wrong pre-game and multiple lads backed after Leinster two weeks ago didn't back it up. A massive reset needed."
One fan noted what many have observed, that the South African should have been shown the exit after committing his future to Bath.
"Embarrassing stuff from Munster - abject end probably sums up Van Graan tenure - overpaid & underdelivered - should’ve been shown the door minute he signed for Bath anyway... Fair play Ulster excellent performance."
The one most optimistic note struck on social was the amount of talent that Munster have unearthed under the Van Graan era - in what could be - by accident or design - the legacy he leaves in the Limerick. The emergence of Gavin Coombes, Craig Casey, Alex Kendallen and the Wycherley brothers, among others; is evidence at least that the province can produce the talent.
The Graham Rowntree era can't come quick enough.
Latest Comments
John, McKenzie was 10 years ago and he only lasted 15 months until the disgustingly unfair affair that brought him down. I thought that if he didn't get another gig over Eddie V2 then he was done. I read that he had been approached but declined to put his name in the ring.
There are no potential Wallaby coaches outside of McKellar unless you have some inside info?
Go to commentsThe way they are defending is sometime pathetic to be honest. Itoje is usually on the inside of the rush and he is paired with a slower tight forward. Unable to keep up with the rush we have seen the line become disconnected on the inside where the big boys are. How many times have we seen Earl rush past the first receiver almost into no mans land covering no attacker. It looks like a system without any guidance. Tome Wright, Ikitau and a number of Wallabies went back to this soft centre as did Williams, Jordan and several others. Also when the line is broken the multiple lines of defence seems to be missing. The rush is predicated on a cover and recovery system with multiple lines of defence but with England you dont see it any more. Fitness and conditioning seems to be off as well as players are struggling to keep up with the intensity of the rush. Felix Jones has left a huge hole. The whole situation was and is a mess. Why they insist on not letting him go and having him work remotely is beyond me. Its leading to massive negative press and is a hot button issue thats distracting from the squad. Also the communication around Jones and his role has been absolute rubbish and is totally disjointed. While some say he is working remotely and playing a role others are saying theres been no contact. His role has not been defined and so people keep asking and keep getting different answers. England need a clean break from him and need to start over. Whatever reason for his leaving its time to cut the rope before the saga drags the whole Borthwick regime down. As for Joe El Abd well good luck to him. He is being made to look like an amateur by the whole saga and he is being asked to coach a system thats not his and which has been perfected and honed since 2017 by Nienaber, Jones, Erasmus and Co and which was first started by White in 2004. He is literally trying to figure out a system pioneered by double world cup winning coaches at the highest level and coach it at the same time. Talk about being on a hiding to nothing.
Go to comments