1
All Blacks player ratings vs Italy | Rugby World Cup 2023
The All Blacks well and truly got their Rugby World Cup back on track on a warm evening in Lyon, thrashing Italy 96-15.
ADVERTISEMENT
New Zealand had seven converted tries on the board by halftime and didn’t let up after the break, grabbing another seven in the second stanza.
How did the All Blacks rate in what was an emphatic victory?
1. Ofa Tu’ungafasi – 6/10
Had the better of Marco Rionni, winning one penalty and one free kick in the first half. Penalised once for playing the ball on the floor when trying to secure an NZ ruck. Off in 50th minute.
2. Codie Taylor – 8
Didn’t get his running game going but did everything else that could be asked of him. Nailed all eight of his lineout deliveries. Grabbed a turnover when Italy were building phases early in the match and then forced a breakdown penalty later in the half. Combined well with Nepo Laulala to flatten one Italian ball-carrier. Off in 57th minute.
3. Nepo Laulala – 6
A rock in the scrums – but also a rock around the park. Didn’t make any errors but largely left the busy work to his teammates. Off in 50th minute.
4. Brodie Retallick – 8
Strong in the lineouts, taking four deliveries for NZ and stealing two off Italian feeds. Put in some monstrous hits, never taking a backwards step. Pinged a couple of times, once for not releasing the tackled player before going for the steal and one for creeping up offside. Made a nice steal at the ensuing lineout to compensate for the latter. Grabbed a try following an Italian error.
5. Scott Barrett – 6
Didn’t stand out in the open field but hit plenty of breakdowns. His charge-down created a try for his locking partner. Pinged for jumping across the lineout. Shifted to blindside flanker for the last half-hour.
ADVERTISEMENT
6. Shannon Frizell – 7
Got involved early on both sides of the ball, making one rollicking tackle. Looked good in the open field but was one of a number of players guilty of not giving the ball to dangerman Will Jordan. Plucked one Italian lineout delivery out of the air when the Azzurri were just five metres out. Off in 50th minute.
7. Dalton Papali’i – 6
Busy on defence but didn’t shine on attack thanks to the more prominent running threats around him. Still, earned himself a try after displaying great hands while running off Mark Telea. The first All Black to hit double digits in the tackle count. Off in 57th minute.
8. Ardie Savea – 9
His best performance of the year. Churned through metres with every carry. Made an excellent break out of New Zealand’s 22 off a short ball from Brodie Retallick, then made the right decision shifting the ball to Beauden Barrett. The All Blacks had their third try of the night seconds later. Again broke through the Italian defence (frankly, all too easily) with his next touch and dived over for a try of his own. Scored a second right on halftime. Assisted Will Jordan’s second with a good supporting run and popped up with the ball in hand on a couple more occasions throughout the second half to finish with 100 carry metres to his name. Penalised in front of the posts for sticking his hands in the ruck and Tommaso Allan wasted no time converting the opportunity into three points.
9. Aaron Smith – 8
Grabbed a try off the back of a push-over maul, which no doubt infuriated his teammates in the pack. Earned himself a second with a nice dart from another forward drive. Had his hat trick in the 34th minute after running a good support line off Jordie Barrett. Off in 50th minute.
ADVERTISEMENT
10. Richie Mo’unga – 7
An understated but relatively cool, calm and collected performance. Hands let him down on a couple occasions. Hit nine out of his 10 attempts on goal. Off in 64th minute.
11. Mark Telea – 8
Did his usual damage on attack but it was his defence that perhaps impressed the most. Busted through a couple of tackles en route to the try line. A big tackle off a high-ball chase almost created a turnover. Made one nice cover tackle. Came close to grabbing a second try late in the third quarter and while he wasn’t able to beat Ange Capuozzo to the ball, he turned around and chased down the Italian wing down, forcing a turnover. Moments later, Telea created a try for Papali’i with a damaging run in the midfield.
12. Jordie Barrett – 9
An excellent return to the field. A perfectly-weighted kick-pass sent Will Jordan in for the first try of the night. Forced one breakdown penalty, getting over the ball quickly after making the tackle. Ran a nice line between two Italian defenders to set up Aaron Smith’s third touch down. Absorbed a couple of big hits from the Azzurri defence. Found good ground with his line kicking but missed touch with one effort. Snuck in a couple of nice flick passes in the midfield. Copped one penalty for not rolling away at the ruck. Off in 64th minute.
13. Rieko Ioane – 4
Regularly made the wrong decision with the ball, running when he should have passed, passing when he should’ve gone into contact. Exposed on defence a couple of times – his failure to bring Monty Ioane to ground resulted in Italy grabbing their only try of the match. Quick hands delivered the ball to Dane Coles for his second touch down.
14. Will Jordan – 7
Did well to plant the ball over the line with a flying dive to grab NZ’s first try. Grabbed a second from a nice kick-and-chase. Always looked threatening on the counter attack and caused plenty of problems down the right-hand flank for Italy. Kicking wasn’t always up to snuff.
View this post on Instagram
15. Beauden Barrett – 7
Regularly stepped into first receiver and never put a foot wrong. Sent one kick-off directly into touch. Showed off his class in the build-up to Telea’s try.
Reserves:
16. Dane Coles – 7
On in 57th minute. Matched his efforts off the bench in 2021, when he scored two tries. Looked good in the wide channels and hit his lineout targets.
17. Tamaiti Williams – 7
On in 50th minute. Maintained New Zealand’s dominance at the scrum, earning two tightheads.
18. Tyrel Lomax – 7
On in 50th minute. Forced one penalty at scrum time.
19. Sam Whitelock – 5
On in 50th minute. Threw the ball to no one on attack – but at least New Zealand were working with an advantage. Now the most capped All Black of all time.
20. Sam Cane – 6
On in 57th minute. A lovely draw and pass off a lineout sent Coles away for his try. Dropped one ball cold.
21. Cam Roigard – 8
On in 50th minute. Made a great dash down the tramways to almost a score a try but was pinged for a double movement. Showed a quick pair of heels to set up a try for Anton Lienert-Brown. Almost managed to tackle Monty Ioane into touch with a nice effort on defence. Well and truly cemented his spot as NZ’s second-best halfback.
22. Damian McKenzie – 8
On in 64th minute. Sparked a nice break down the right-hand flank with his first touch – a perfect skip pass out to Jordan on the wing. Scored when he next got his next hands on the ball, showing a clean pair of heels and cutting between two Italian defenders. Clocked up an impressive 75 metres off the bench. Made one important cover tackle when Italy were looking likely. Continued the good goal-kicking, succeeding with his two attempts on the poles.
23. Anton Lienert-Brown – 7
On in 64th minute. Looked dangerous in the midfield and ran good lines off his teammates. Made one excellent covering hit on Paolo Odogwu.
Tom Vinicombe, Italy scored two (2) tries. You wrote that Savea's missed tackle allowed them their only try of the match! For that slight error I can only give you 4 out of 10.
8 for DMac?? He's almost solely responsible for that 2nd late game Italian try. So tired of the rose colored glasses look at DMac that ignore all his frenetic errors and muckups on the field.
Sole his fault you mean it was Jordans fault as he was outside man definitely not dmacks fault your comment just proves you know absolutely nothing about the game
Yes, I agree. I thought i was the only one who was seeing this. At least Steve Hansen agreed that Richie & Beauden deserve their place on the field over DMac. Chaos play seems to happen when DMac is on attack.
6 for Cane for making one simple pass? Replace him on bench with Blackadder. He will get tossed around like a rag doll against Ireland
Blackkadder come back and was terrible blackadder isn't as good as everyone things he is cane is better than Blackadder and the super rugby proved that
Dupont's injury global news but chirping of crickets for Canes.
To be fair Savea's the one out of the two that gets rag dolled.
Savea and Jordan predictably shone in the tier 2 contest.
The NZ loose forward combo is way off, Dalton should start at 7 with Savea off the bench.
Frizzell should start at 8 with Blackadder at 6. Jacobson and Whitelock also on the bench.
Cane should be the non playing captain like in 87.
Was at the game - ABs played well. The kicking was still aimless - especially BB and Jordan. The loose forwards were excellent!
Haha these ratings are hilarious. What did the author think the game was over at half time and considered that the 80th minute scoreline?
I would have subbed Ardie and Nugget at the half mark, they did so well, Ardie especially with his energy. What a waste to keep him on, would have liked to see Frizell at 8 for 10 to 15 minutes.
Would have been nice for Sam Whitelock to run onto the park at half time with everyone too I reckon. Push SB to 6 so that he had the whole half to get accustomed to that possible eventuality.
Yes I'm a better Coach than Mark Foster, I fully believe it.
Savea always looks awesome at training
Who's Mark Foster hahaha
Yeah I thought Ardie and Nuggy could have come off at half time. Keeping Ardie on for the full 80 was a bit unnecessary - don’t want any injury surprises.
I suspect that they didn't actually watch the game.
"his failure to bring Monty Ioane to ground resulted in Italy grabbing their only try of the match"
I could forgive losing track of how many the All Blacks scored but if they don't know that Italy scored 2 then they didn't watch the game.
Like the Aussie supporters who left before game against Wales was finnished, Tom did the same & missed seeing Italys 2nd try. Rate him 2 out of 10 & that’s been generous
Last name checks out for an Italian support in my book.
Well lots to like
Savea and Will obviously getting mojo back was great.
Frizz looked hungry and good to see lomax and cane seem ok too. Jordie back means a lot more variation to our attack and kicking. And actually with Jordie also being another playmaker it really showed we don’t need BB at 15. Really do think we need Will at 15, Liester 11, telia 14 and then Jordie 12 and ALB at 13
Reiko had a terrible game and this game highlighted so many of his issues
Chances that maybe only come his way 2-3 times in a proper game were x4-5 today and nearly everytime he got it wrong. From not passing to passsing when he should have run missed tackles, turnovers it was very evident he still is a big issue
Elsewhere the Auckland props scrummed well but non existent anywhere else - nowhere near the level of Ireland French or SA props workrates. Lineout worked well and Brodie was huge around the park. I’m worried about scooter he seems to have gone down a notch since cards seems to have lost Confidence
Looking good for QFs but still think the team make up could be better
I wonder if its possible to find someone else to do these ratings. This author doesn't seem to watch the same game as the rest of us.
Well lots to like
Savea and Will obviously getting mojo back was great.
Frizz looked hungry and good to see lomax and cane seem ok too. Jordie back means a lot more variation to our attack and kicking. And actually with Jordie also being another playmaker it really showed we don’t need BB at 15. Really do think we need Will at 15, Liester 11, telia 14 and then Jordie 12 and ALB at 13
Reiko had a terrible game and this game highlighted so many of his issues
Chances that maybe only come his way 2-3 times in a proper game were x4-5 today and nearly everytime he got it wrong. From not passing to passsing when he should have run missed tackles, turnovers it was very evident he still is a big issue
Elsewhere the Auckland props scrummed well but non existent anywhere else - nowhere near the level of Ireland French or SA props workrates. Lineout worked well and Brodie was huge around the park. I’m worried about scooter he seems to have gone down a notch since cards seems to have lost Confidence
Looking good for QFs but still think the team make up could be better
Too often the starter tight 4, props & locks, are undervalued in these rankings with hookers, backrowers, & backs getting the chocolates. For example, to give ALB a 7 for 17mins while giving 6s & below to props & locks, is just plain rubbish. Why the hell do you think we were 68-10 up by the time ALB came on? I mean, when we lose who gets the blame? You got it, props & locks.
Tbf a hooker's scored gets destroyed if the lineouts are off, even if it's an issue with lifters and jumpers.
Hmm not sure Tom was watching the same game 🤔. Front row were excellent - laid platform - & so were the loosies. Scott B , Paps, & the boppers deserve better than 6. Beauden is a journeyman these days; linked well but still wants to kick first.. Macker - superb. Crisp passing, creates space; must be tempted to throw him the keys.
Cane also missed at least one tackle - 5. If Foster persists with him, it should be the back-up role like today's game. Papali'i went better than a 6 rating in my opinion and there seemed to be more of an effort at the breakdown by the whole team today. Not anywhere near Ireland's breakdown accuracy but a huge step up on recent efforts. Ioane did get exposed in defense and still dies with the ball rather than linking - and was not the only one trying too hard to keep the ball alive when tackled at the expense of knock-ons. Front row should change up when DeGroot and Lomax are both ready again.
agree, how did Cane get same mark as Dalton.???? Cane did nothing but drop a simple pass. Dalton was monster in the counter ruck and brilliant hands for his try
I think De Groot may have a problem with his suspension ending only by the time of the QF. It is not a great time to be making a change. Lomax played with authority when he came on but Williams was also really powerful in the scrum. I’m not a great fan of the ‘Blues Bros’ (Laulala and Tu’ungafasi) but I would not be surprised if they hold onto their positions with Lomax and Williams being used for impact from the bench again. The selectors seem to favour the Blues Bros for their experience and the fact they didn’t concede any penalties. Lomax and Williams combine well because of their similar body height and they are more likely to create an impact than Laulala and Tu’ungafasi.
I do agree with the assessment of Cane though. All prejudice aside, he was the sub that did the least when he came on and Savea seems to be a better captain too.
I think we had Lomax back for this game - he looked quite good, I thought. Looking forward to getting DeGroot back.
Incredibly low scores given the demolition job of a tier 1 side, bigger margin than they had against Namibia.
One can only assume you recorded the ratings here before the game to save time.
Considering he wrote the words “their only try of the game” on Riekos review one would assume so.
Telea only 7? Savea only 8? The two standouts surely deserved better scores than Jordie, who was very good but not the best player of the match.