Caleb Clarke handed ban following aerial challenge against Moana Pasifika
Blues left wing Caleb Clarke has been suspended for his role in the aerial challenge on Moana Pasifika's Tomasi Alosio at Eden Park last weekend.
The 23-year-old was shown a red card when his attempted charge down went wrong and he ended up colliding with Alosio's head.
The judiciary committee ruled that Clarke's aerial challenge was dangerous play under law 9.11 and determined a suspension of three weeks, which will see the Blues star miss crucial games against the Chiefs, Crusaders and Fijian Drua.
Clarke's good judicial record and remorse saw a reduction in the suspension from a potential six weeks to three.
Judicial Committee Chair Stephen Hardy ruled that the accident constituted 'foul play', which required a mid-range entry for the suspension:
"With respect to sanction, the Judicial Committee deemed the act of foul play merited a mid-range entry point of six weeks due to the World Rugby directive that mandates that any incident of foul play involving contact with the head must start at a mid-range entry level," the statement read.
"Taking into account mitigating factors, including the Player's good judicial record, the manner he held himself through the proceedings, expressed remorse with multiple attempts to check on the injured player, and his young age; the Judicial Committee reduced the suspension by three weeks."
NZ Herald's rugby writer Liam Napier reacted to the suspension with surprise, saying the 'game has lost the plot' after failing to use common sense at the hearing.
By all accounts there was no malice or intent on Clarke's behalf, with the jump becoming an accidental challenge once the charge down was missed. By ruling the act as 'foul play', SANZAAR have set a new precedent.
Latest Comments
There is nothing particularly significant about Ireland in this regard compared to other Tier 1 nations. To look at 'strategy' for illegal play its best to see what teams push boundaries with new laws. SA have milked two tries at ruck block downs. The strategy is to charge the first few before the ball is out at about 4 seconds but pull out and put up hands in reigned apology. The referees usually allow the scum half to clear without awarding a penalty in this scenario. The problem with that being that the scrumhalf is now taking over 5 seconds through no fault of his own. Having achieved a few slow balls > 5s , the SA forward can now pick a scrum to charge dead on 5s. Now if the scrum half waits, he will concede a penalty, as we saw against Scotland. With the new rule in place, any early charge should result in an immediate penalty.
SA also got an offside block against England which was pivotal again after a couple of 'apologetic' offside aborted charges forcing England to clear slowly.
Go to commentsYep, you're not the sharpest tool in the shed are you?
Go to comments