Ex-Bok Robbie Fleck addresses previous criticism of Marcus Smith

Despite only playing two matches in the Guinness Six Nations, both from the bench, Marcus Smith had some standout moments in the tournament.
From his match-winning drop-goal against Ireland to his try against France, the 25-year-old made an undeniable impact as a substitute.
After watching England put in three uninspiring performances in the opening three rounds while he was out with a calf injury, the Harlequin would have wanted to show what an asset he is to England on his return, while also making a statement to some of his critics, one of which was former South Africa centre Robbie Fleck.
Fleck had said on RPTV's Boks Office before England's win over Ireland that he did not think the fly-half was the "answer" for England.
Two matches later, and two vastly improved performances by England later, Fleck returned to Boks Office and addressed those comments.
The 31-cap Bok qualified his statement that Smith was not the answer for England by saying he was not the answer in their style at the beginning of the Championship. He still, however, believes George Ford deserves to start for England in the No10 jersey, but said that Smith "proved his worth" from the bench.
With that said, despite playing the majority of the match against France at fullback after replacing George Furbank early in the game, neither Fleck, nor fellow Springbok Schalk Burger, see Smith as a viable starter at fullback for England moving forward.
"I still say that while England were going through a transition in style of play, was he the right choice as a starting No10? The answer is no," Fleck said.
"But he has certainly improved his worth coming off the bench. When he came on against Ireland, he just added so much flavour to the set-up. The Irish allowed him to attack.
"The drop-goal at the end, any fly-half worth his salt should have done that. But he had those subtle little changes in pace and he did one little short ball to a loose forward and he wrapped around and got into space and that put Ireland on the back foot.
"The time and space that he was given by the French was just too much and that's when he starts to dominate.
"I think he's fulfilling his role coming off the bench. But as a starter, George Ford for me was outstanding. This whole series he's been brilliant.
"But Marcus Smith has proven his worth coming off the bench and changing the game."
Latest Comments
Thank you. Graham
Go to comments“I was wondering if the AIL had clubs that were on the tipping point of wanting to become pro, how close could they get to a current Ulster etc”.
The Irish structure has always been the International team at the top, then the four provinces, then the clubs below that. Before the pro era in each province there were senior clubs playing each other, and that was pretty much “ring fenced”…no relegation or promotion. Then below that a series of junior leagues. The top players in the international scene played in the Five Nations(before Italy came in), and against the touring All Blacks or Springboks initially, then later Australia and Argentina came in. Actually I would need to go back and check the history of the teams coming onto the scene ie other than the Ab’s and Boks.
Those International players would only play for their province three times each year in the Inter Pro games, with the Bok, AB etc games only in tour years. Rest of the time, every single Int. player played club rugby every weekend.
Pro era dawned, and the four provinces became the sole pro teams, feeding up to the Int. team. There is no prospect as far as I can see of any AIL team ever becoming professional. Deepete, or someone living in Ireland would know more than I do, but what happens is fringe and academy players can play in the AIL, giving them game time they would not get otherwise. Top International players would rarely play at AIL level.
I think in Australia the tyranny of distance inhibits an AIL type structure. Ireland is tiny, good rail and road sytems, and it is easy to play in Cork, Limerick, Dublin, any where, weekend after weekend. Imagine an All Australian league, and travelling from Townsville for a game in Margaret River, etc. etc.
“I actually had the tables up and had no idea who was who lol”. Neither do I in some cases. A lot of new clubs since I played/lived in Ireland…I have to check who some are !!
Good discussion here JW. Have enjoyed it.
Go to comments