The one Wales selection ripped as 'demoralising' by Ian Gough
Former Wales lock Ian Gough has criticized Cory Hill's unexpected international recall as "demoralising" for home-based players.
Hill, 32, last played for Wales three years ago and is currently with Japanese fourth division team Secom Rugguts.
Due to a second-row crisis in Wales, Hill has been included in Warren Gatland's squad for matches against South Africa and Australia.
The crisis is due to injuries to Adam Beard, Rhys Davies and Teddy Williams, Seb Davies's suspension, and Will Rowlands being rested.
Exeter's Dafydd Jenkins and Christ Tshiunza are also unavailable for the Springboks Test. Gough - who earned 64 caps from 1998 to 2009 - argued Gatland's decision sends the "wrong message" to other players.
"For Cory Hill to get the red carpet back into the Wales squad grates on me," Gough told Radio Wales Sport. "He went to Japan for money, which is fine, but how can you pick someone who has been playing park rugby in Japan for a squad to play South Africa."
Hill initially moved to Japan to join the Yokohama Canon Eagles from Cardiff. In 2023 he transitioned to fourth division team Secom Rugguts - a move which offered financial incentives but a significantly less demanding standard of rugby. He could now be set to face the Springboks, arguably the sport's most physical Test side.
"He was a fantastic player but you should always judge on form and when was the last time he played a top-end game?
"When was the last time he was tested at any level, even a Champions Cup game or a URC quarter-final?"
"I don't agree with it. It doesn't send a good message to those players who stayed in Wales to ply their trade.
"It must be very demoralising for someone like Morgan Morris who has shown real consistency over the years and doesn't get in.
"Perhaps there is method in the madness but it seems like throwing a feather in the air and seeing which way the wind blows."
Latest Comments
Thanks Nick. Surely they will thump Japan this week and the pressure will be off. Do you want to make a prediction that the defence coach will go before the Six Nations? England seem to want Borthwick there for a long time so surely they will back Bortho and look for a new defence coach?
Go to commentsYes, Carlos, I sensed before hand this would be a very close game, even could see an Arg. win....well, they have beaten all their three SH compatriots this year, then added Italy. And as nick says below, they were winners of the breakdown for a lot of the game, and both sides of the ball too.
Felipe very highly regarded in Ireland, esp. Leinster.
Good luck this weekend !
Go to comments