Northern Edition
Select Edition
Northern Northern
Southern Southern
Global Global
New Zealand New Zealand
France France

France inflict record defeat on England in Six Nations humbling

By PA
(left to right) England's Freddie Stewart, Jack van Poortvliet, Ellis Genge and Marcus Smith react after conceding a try during the Guinness Six Nations match at Twickenham Stadium, London. Picture date: Saturday March 11, 2023. (Photo by Ben Whitley/PA Images via Getty Images)

England were overwhelmed 53-10 by France at Twickenham in a record defeat that removed them from Guinness Six Nations title contention and delivered an alarming reality check to Steve Borthwick’s rebuilding project.

ADVERTISEMENT

Trailing 27-3 at half-time – their highest interval deficit at Twickenham in any fixture – they were in the midst of full-blown crisis having been taken apart up front.

Thomas Ramos, Thibaud Flament and Charles Ollivon had crossed with alarming ease and England looked completely lost as fault lines opened in their defence, kicking, breakdown and discipline.

Video Spacer
Video Spacer

The arrival of Owen Farrell and Alex Mitchell off the bench early in the second half came amid an uprising that produced a try for Freddie Steward, but it was short-lived as Flament, Ollivon and Damian Penaud propelled France further in front.

The gulf between the rivals was embarrassing as the World Cup hosts registered their first Six Nations victory at Twickenham since 2005 in a glorious return to form having laboured through much of the tournament.

And it only gets harder for Borthwick’s men as, having faced the team positioned second in the global rankings, they must travel to Dublin next Saturday to take on Grand Slam-chasing Ireland, who occupy the summit.

Marcus Smith did everything he could having ousted Farrell at fly-half, but with his forwards dismantled at every turn he was powerless to halt the collapse.

ADVERTISEMENT

For all the talk of England playing with pace, it was France who raced out of the blocks and when lock Paul Willemse offloaded out of the tackle they were away, with Ethan Dumortier sending Ramos over in the left corner.

Ramos added a penalty to reward another Les Bleus attack and with only 10 minutes on the clock it was already looking bleak for the hosts.

England were hamstrung by their discipline at the breakdown and apart from a forceful run by Steward they were struggling to make any impression as rain began to fall.

Inroads were made through the maul but with Jack van Poortvliet fumbling again, the progress was lost and the familiar sight of France rampaging downfield resumed.

ADVERTISEMENT

Antoine Dupont grew in influence as he weaved his magic around the ruck but it was the power of forwards François Cros and Flament that did the damage for the next try.

Flament crossed in the 26th minute but it was too easy for the lock as passive England were overpowered in contact.

And their scrum defence was horribly exposed in first-half injury-time when Gregory Alldritt charged forward and seeing blue shirts lined up in support, sent Ollivon crashing over.

England needed to act quickly and hope appeared to have arrived when Smith delivered a terrific kick on the run for Max Malins but the wing knocked-on over the line.

It was now France’s defence that was disintegrating and after waves of attacks they were breached with Steward riding a tackle to slide over.

England quickly renewed their attack but the fightback faltered when a cruel bounce deceived their backfield defence, allowing Romain Ntamack to flick the ball to Flament who scored.

And there was more misfortune when Smith was driven over his line by Dupont as he covered for a kick and Ollivon touched down when he let go of the ball before two late tries by wing Penaud drove the final nail into England’s coffin.

ADVERTISEMENT

Toshiba Brave Lupus Tokyo vs Kubota Spears | Japan Rugby League One 2024/25 Final | Full Match Replay

Saitama Wild Knights vs Kobe Steelers | Japan Rugby League One 2024/25 Bronze Final | Full Match Replay

Boks Office | Episode 42 | Investec Champions Cup Final Review

Spain's Incredible Rugby Sevens Journey to the World Championship Final | HSBC SVNS Embedded | Episode 14

Australia vs USA | Pacific Four Series 2025 | Full Match Replay

New Zealand vs Canada | Pacific Four Series 2025 | Full Match Replay

South Africa vs New Zealand | The Rugby Championship U20's | Full Match Replay

The Game that Made Jonah Lomu

Trending on RugbyPass

Comments

1 Comment
G
GrahamVF 823 days ago

Well well well. Steve is clearly out of his depth at international level and the pile of s$&t he says he inherited from Eddie just got a lot more smelly.

Join free and tell us what you really think!

Sign up for free
ADVERTISEMENT

Latest Features

Comments on RugbyPass

A
Anendra Singh 1 hour ago
Super Rugby Pacific's greatest season stained by one playoff game

I wrote posts on this on two rugby union FB platforms on June 9 (NZ time). I took it further to not only label this QF a “dead rubber” but also if the two sides had manufactured a win, with the Blues taking a raincheck on paying back the Chiefs in a future season, when a bottle neck arises.

Speculation? Indeed, but worth it to inject some credibility in SRP. With flagging interest in what has been a weak SRP, there needs to be some meaningful discussions around what needs to be done to make SRP a platform to select ABs/Wallabies from.

Now, I had reactions of “conspiracy theories” but it basically questions the motive of a repechage “Lucky Loser” facet because it only opens the playoffs to manipulation. It’s called the knockout stage for a reason. You snooze; you lose. No sweeteners required.

The only reason organisers opted for the Top 6 is for a revenue-gathering exercise but, it seems, it has backfired. The 8 qualifying format was a joke, akin to the Blues losing so many games and still making the playoffs. That smacks of the previous seasons’ dilemma.

It’s also worth noting some pool games were questionable because elite teams had done their homework on what boxes to tick for wins and which ones to forfeit. For example, Chiefs and Tahs had not performed in Lautoka against Fijian Drua on what is perceived to be a hostile pitch. Tahs had rested all Wallabies and marquee players.

The only option to retain integrity in SRP is to make to a Top 4. Cut your losses to win back the fans’ faith.

59 Go to comments
f
frandinand 5 hours ago
The Reds' 'whimpering' exit shows Super Rugby scrums still matter

My favorite wine used to be Shiraz and I also enjoy a nice malbec. But having discovered quality pinots my preferences have definitely changed. Sorry Nic. But the great red wines of the world are pinots. The problem is being able to afford them. A friend in NZ sent me this list of their top 25 across regions prices and styles Hope you can source some of them Carlos.

Grove Mill 2023 Marlborough Pinot Noir - $15.99

Ayrburn Whimsy 2019 Otago Pinot Noir - $19.99

Mount Brown 2023 Waipara Pinot Noir - $19.99

Rapaura Springs Reserve 2023 Marlborough Pinot Noir - $21.99

Te Kairanga Estate 2024 Martinborough Pinot Noir - $24.99

Terra Sancta Mysterious Diggings 2024 Otago Pinot Noir - $26.99

Hunters 2023 Marlborough Pinot Noir – $26.99

Clearview Estate 2024 Martinborough Pinot Noir - $27.99

Putangi 2024 Otago Pinot Noir - $27.99

McArthur Ridge Southern Tor 2024 Otago Pinot Noir - $35.99

Ata Rangi Crimson 2023 Martinborough Pinot Noir - $38.99

Neudorf Tom’s Block 2023 Moutere Pinot Noir - $38.99

Te Kairanga John Martin 2024 Martinborough Pinot Noir - $39.99

Terra Sancta Shingle Beach 2024 Otago Pinot Noir - $43.99

Pyramid Valley Manatu 2022 Otago Pinot Noir - $44.99

Maude Mohawk 2023 Otago Pinot Noir - $49.99

Misha’s High Note 2021 Otago Pinot Noir - $50.99

Quartz Reef Bendigo 2022 Otago Pinot Noir - $52.99

Amisfield 2022 Otago Pinot Noir - $61.99

Calvert Bannockburn 2021 Otago Pinot Noir - $64.99

Prophet's Rock Home Vineyard 2023 Otago Pinot Noir - $79.99

Greystone Vineyard Ferment 2021 Waipara Pinot Noir - $81.99

Amisfield Breakneck Reserve 2022 Otago Pinot Noir - $92.99

Clos Ostler Caroline’s 2021 Waitaki Pinot Noir - $112.99

145 Go to comments
LONG READ
LONG READ Dave Kilcoyne: ‘These days, you can’t really throw a punch because you’ll be caught on the drone footage!’ Dave Kilcoyne: ‘These days, you can’t really throw a punch because you’ll be caught on the drone footage!’
Search