1
France player ratings vs England
By Ian Cameron
France player ratings: Galthie's team of athletic, young Frenchman might have been light in experience but they made up for it with attacking accuracy, dynamism and aggression.
What is clear is that defensively, Shaun Edwards has had a big effect on this team.
ANTHONY BOUTHIER 8
Looked assured with his first touch of the ball and again in the 8th minute when clearing the French lines after an unsympathetic pass from Thomas. Eddie Butler nearly wet himself with his enormous clearance in the 26th minute. A real find.
TEDDY THOMAS 7
His 10 metre carry in the 5th minute sent England into panic mode and it ultimately led to France's first try. The only blot(s) in his copybook were getting beaten for pace by Jonny May not once, but twice.
Continue reading below...
WATCH: England player Tom Curry and coach Simon Amor give a press conference ahead of England's first Six Nations game against France.
VIRIMI VAKATAWA 6
Not his most exciting day at the office. He's Europe's form attacking threat, but these conditions didn't suit him. Played his part in defence.
GAËL FICKOU 6
A relatively quiet first half for the now veteran centre. Largely defensive sound alongside Vakatawa.
VINCENT RATTEZ 8
A late replacement for Penaud, but if there were any nerves they weren't on show. The lithe wing brilliantly handed off Ben Youngs for the opening try. Unlucky not to grab the intercept in the 67th minute, which would have killed off the game.
ROMAIN NTAMACK 7
The Toulousain kicked well from hand and from the tee. You have to remind yourself that he is a 20-year-old. Did he look a little uneasy when England started to come back into the game in the last 25 minutes? Maybe.
ANTOINE DUPONT 8.5
His electric breaks caused all sorts of problems for England. The fact that he stayed on for the full 80 minutes shows how much Galthie rates him. Huge hit on Willi Heinz in the 77th minute was the cherry on top. His time keeping needs work.
CYRIL BAILLE 7
Carried exceptionally well early on. The French scrum started going backwards when he went off.
JULIEN MARCHAND 6
After a wobbly start he got to grips with the lineout. Keeping Camille Chat's seat warm.
MOHAMED HAOUAS 6
Played his part in bullying England's pack, both in the tackle and at the set-piece.
BERNARD LE ROUX 7
Has played for France in both the second-row and back-row. Was a vital cog in the French pack's muscular defence and dominated his collision more often than not. The only argument against him in the secondrow is that it lowers France's size.
PAUL WILLEMSE 6
The massive South African is renowned for his brutal short carries, but was the Montpellier lock was kept relatively quiet by England's pack. Spilt the ball on occasion.
FRANCOIS CROS 7.5
Bossed and harried England at the lineout, his 24th minute steal a standout moment.
CHARLES OLLIVON (CAPTAIN) 8.5
The athletic French captain was everywhere. Part of a trend in France towards tall, athletic French backrows and easily had to pace to take his 19th-minute try. A few spills in the rain are completely forgivable. Magnificent.
GREGORY ALLDRITT 8.5
He made a replacement appearance at number eight for Louis Picamoles in the 24-19 Six Nations
defeat by Wales at Stade de France nearly exactly a year ago, and has made the shirt his own. Seems to always make metres in contact. His 32nd minute turnover on the French line was a turning point.
REPLACEMENTS:
PEATO MAUVAKA 4
All he managed was a lineout over-throw in the 13 minutes he was on the field. In his defence France were coming apart at the seams at that stage.
JEFFERSON POIROT 7
Was excellent when he came on early in the second half. Won two penalties, which were priceless in the wet conditions. However, the French scrum was under serious pressure in the second half.
DEMBA BAMBA 5.5
As Paul O'Connell suggested, a fit Bamba will be a sight to see for the rugby world. However, the French scrum deteriorated in the second half, and he has to take some of the responsibility for that.
BORIS PALU 6
Replaced Willemse in the secondrow. Pounced on a loose ball in the 71st minute which was crucial.
CAMERON WOKI 6
The 21-year-old didn't shy away from work when he came on.
BAPTISTE SERIN NA
MATTHIEU JALIBERT NA
Not on long enough to rate.
Trending on RugbyPass
2
South Africa vs England player ratings | 2024 Autumn Nations Series
3
All Blacks player ratings vs France
4
Netherlands serve up Tier 2 shock as another World Cup side slayed
5
Latest Comments
At least he no longer writes articles related to the All Blacks. The suggestion with these ratings is that the ABs have a lot more left in the tank... Which is nonsense, this was a nail biter of a test of the highest standard and both sides we're going at it hammer and tongs. As is often the case in rugby, the team that managed to score the most tries won.
Go to commentsWho, the ABs? Oh for sure, they punched above their weight in that cup, but also had got a lot better than anyone had thought they could (except perhaps SAn's) well out from the WC (to the point where you were disappointed not to win it). Then they've probably done the most post analyzing of their RWCs in the past, due to all their failures, they knew how to maximize their itinerary and that first game against France was of less importance than any one off test was against. At least a test like this weekends had meaning, even if it's not surrounded by any overarching point. That first match in the RWC though, along with the Ireland v SA game, were totally meaningless. Everyone already knew they were only going to be up against each other, and that's why NZ were only at around 70% during it.
So you're quite right, it was pointless to make as much out of it as this author did. The same pretty much goes for 2 years prior as well, because that's obviously before the above happened. NZ were at least trying very hard in that game, and although it needed some Ntamack magic at the end, France looked pretty comfortable, or should I say, NZ very poor. That picture obviously turned around this year, but still with that fabulous French flair scoring some crazy tries to win it again.
Go to comments