Galthie opens old wound with rebuke of RWC referee and one Springbok
Five months after France crashed out of their own World Cup at the hands of eventual winners South Africa, Fabien Galthie has revisited the fateful quarter-final match in Paris to take aim at the refereeing performance of Ben O'Keeffe.
Speaking at a review of France's recent Guinness Six Nations campaign in Marcoussis, the head coach of Les Bleus addressed the 29-28 loss to the Springboks, something that many believe had an impact on their recent form.
While France captain Antoine Dupont was forthright in his excoriation of the officiating in the aftermath of the loss, Galthie was much more reserved. However, he took the opportunity this week to discuss the topic.
“We lost the quarter-final for rugby reasons but also for refereeing decisions," he said, as reported by French outlet Midi Olympique (translated by Google).
"We also spoke about it with Ben O'Keeffe during a recent meeting at World Rugby.
"The decision is part of the match and we accept it. You will never see me react directly to an arbitration decision. But we can discuss it coldly.
"In a World Rugby committee, I therefore had the opportunity to speak with Ben O'Keeffe.
"At one point in the meeting there was a discussion about the behaviour of the selectors. I took the floor and said that we had a major role as educators and that we must behave with respect towards the referees. This is fundamental.
"I told him that my players had been strongly impacted by questionable decisions. Everyone agreed on the fact that some decisions weren't the right ones. He wasn't at all happy with his performance either."
The South Africa players themselves were not out of the firing line of the former scrumhalf's rebuke, with flanker Kwagga Smith being singled out.
"There is a ball stolen with elbows on the ground by Kwagga Smith which gives three points to the Springboks, for example.
"We today we want to count on the work of regulation and rules undertaken in these World Rugby committees. We must make our voice heard."
France finished second in this year's Six Nations, beating Wales and England in the final two rounds of the Championship.
Following a dismal loss to Ireland in the opening round, Galthie's side scraped to a win over Scotland in round two before drawing to Italy in Lille- a result whereby they were saved by Paolo Garbisi's infamous late penalty miss.
Galthie and his coaching staff were under serious pressure heading into the final two rounds, but he may well have saved his job with two markedly improved performances, capped by an epic 33-31 win over England in Lyon.
Latest Comments
"fl's idea, if I can speak for him to speed things up, was for it to be semifinalists first, Champions Cup (any that somehow didn't make a league semi), then Challenge's semi finalists (which would most certainly have been outside their league semi's you'd think), then perhaps the quarter finalists of each in the same manner. I don't think he was suggesting whoever next performed best in Europe but didn't make those knockouts (like those round of 16 losers), I doubt that would ever happen."
That's not quite my idea.
For a 20 team champions cup I'd have 4 teams qualify from the previous years champions cup, and 4 from the previous years challenge cup. For a 16 team champions cup I'd have 3 teams qualify from the previous years champions cup, and 1 from the previous years challenge cup.
"The problem I mainly saw with his idea (much the same as you see, that league finish is a better indicator) is that you could have one of the best candidates lose in the quarters to the eventual champions, and so miss out for someone who got an easier ride, and also finished lower in the league, perhaps in their own league, and who you beat everytime."
If teams get a tough draw in the challenge cup quarters, they should have won more pool games and so got better seeding. My system is less about finding the best teams, and more about finding the teams who perform at the highest level in european competition.
Go to commentsWalter has been permanently psychologically damaged since his wife left him and moved in with a man from Sydney.
Go to comments