1
Have the All Blacks regressed or is the world just catching up?
There were plenty of calls around New Zealand following the All Blacks’ less-than-impressive end-of-year tour at the end of last season that head coach Ian Foster simply wasn’t the man to lead the team forward.
ADVERTISEMENT
Defeats at the hands of South Africa, Ireland and France capped off a disappointing campaign and a first-ever home loss at the hands of the Irish over the weekend has now reinvigorated Foster’s vocal opposition.
Whichever way you look at it, Foster’s time in charge of the national side – which has seen the All Blacks claim 11 wins from 18 matches against tier-one opposition – has been a disappointment.
Video Player is loading.
But, it’s worth noting that NZ’s dismal record in recent times may not simply be a product of the All Blacks flailing under Foster’s stewardship.
Until 2016, Ireland had never tasted victory over New Zealand but claimed a historic win at Soldier Field in Chicago. On the six occasions since, the spoils have been shared evenly.
The change in the tide can be partially accredited to a fall in NZ’s standing but it would be disingenuous to suggest that there hasn’t also been a massive growth in Ireland’s game over the past decade.
Ireland have always been a good side but they’ve generally struggled to consistently match it with the likes of England and France in the north, and New Zealand, Australia and South Africa in the south.
ADVERTISEMENT
That’s changed in recent times, however, with Ireland transforming themselves throughout Joe Schmidt’s tenure as head coach, and further evolving under the guidance of Andy Farrell.
Over their last three matches against each of the tier-one nations, France and South Africa are the only two sides that Ireland haven’t had the better of.
Australia, Wales and Argentina have won just one of their past five matches against Ireland while Scotland are sitting on five losses.
Ireland have triumphed in their most recent two matches against England and, in fact, France is the only tier-one nation who Ireland didn’t win their most recent match against, with Les Bleus grabbing a six-point victory in Paris during this year’s Six Nations.
ADVERTISEMENT
The fact of the matter is, Ireland are an exceptionally well constructed and well coached side and while the All Blacks’ recent run of results against the northerners is less than impressive, the defeat in Chicago was always going to pave the way for greater Irish success.
It’s also worth noting that while the All Blacks have slid down the World Rankings on the back of their latest loss to a historically low fourth place, they will bounce back up to second with a win in Wellington on Saturday evening.
Of course, all of the above is not to suggest that there aren’t changes that could or should be made in the All Blacks’ set-up – but New Zealand’s reign at the top was never going to last forever and a few losses to other nations who are at the peak of their powers is not necessarily the doom and gloom that many are making it out to be.
I would like to add in though ., New Zealand had one of the most strict covid laws in the world . And no sport was played for a while . AB s were slow to start but they will get their groove back ...
It's clearly a bit of both. But also the succession planning after the sports most dominant ever team ended was poor. It was such a long of total dominance that it's hardly surprising. The biggest mistake would be to assume that the decline is terminal though.
The biggest hurdle is the robotic coaching regimes of our Super Rugby franchises.
Some blame must also be laid at the feet over the overwhelmingly NH-focussed World Rugby organisation. Their inability to have a sensible Card system and their pursuing over an overly-refereed game has spoiled the fair contest.
NZ Rugby's complete refusal to acknowledge new rules exist is to blame. The coaches don't coach it, the referees don't referee it. No surprises that when they get to the international stage we get carded out of the game. We have a terminal discipline problem, and now that we have a reputation for it referees are on the look out for anything we do. To see the coach now whinging about the referee enforcing the laws of the game that everyone else seems to be able to play by is embarrassing.
You mean actually enforceing the rules of the game
A bit of both. The AB'S have definitely regressed. But most of the tier 1 nations have improved drastically.
Agree... The All Blacks have that natural genetic talent that is unmatched(see Brasil and football)...Maybe the French can match them with their Flair. But sadly it seems, the 100+ plus years of domination is coming to an end..weird that from 2010 to 2017...they probably had one of the finest sides to ever play the game blessed with a plethora of once in a generation players..
I remember back in my high school days the unofficial IRB world rankings were as follows:
1) NZ "A"
2) NZ "B"
3) Crusaders... then the rest of the world...
To say its been downhill from there may be an understatement.
Current squad seems to lack any out-and-out X factor players that I can think off ..whereas before the previous squad was littered with basically a World XV of players.
As Ireland's O'Mahony even noted that Sam Cane is a poor man's Riche McCaw...enuf said...
The rest of the world has definately caught up in terms of conditioning/ fitness and tactical gameplans to negate free flowing Maverick players/teams...Just look at the blunt hammer approach teams like the Boks/England and Wales use to halt forward momentum which makes it difficult for natural creative players to get a foot hold..there is just simply not enough time for the backline to work their magic...
A solution may be to hybridize the loose forwards...Big and brutish enough to carry but skillful enough to act as hybrid centres that can step and create space and buy time....BUT if anyone has the ability to revolutionize the game..its the All Blacks.
New Zealand's fall from grace can be largely attributed to two main facets. 1) Woefully inadequate coaching staff that is still overly reliant on outdated tactis and 2) Tier 1 nations that have observed the All Blacks game for years and adjusted accordingly. These teams are now more powerful at the breakdown, slow down NZ ball and are playing rugby with an intensity that the ABs simply cannot cope with (e.g. rush defense). The forward pack is arguably where the collisions need to be won and New Zealand are in no position to field forwards that are better than their adversaries.
Well said. Agree on all points