'If a player gets caught taking drugs it should be a jail sentence because you're stealing a living'

Who participates in that choice is an essential component. Obv broadcasters and sponsors pay the wages ultimately, so they will have a voice, as will the LNR/FFR. The third prong has to be an org representing the players interests directly.

For those French players who were not involved in the Top14 playoffs, yet approaching and breaking the 2000’/25 games criteria, like Fickou, Auradou, Le Garrec or Guillard, were the 3 weeks enough to rest between the last game of the season and the first test?

A key question, to which my answer would be ‘No’. Mental and physical fatigue in a high-octane collision sport is cumulative, and at a certain point there is no real recovery possible. You can refill a car with petrol endlessly but it also needs a full service - which means for rugby players a proper off-season. In a comparable sport like American Football that is seven months, in rugby the French players would be lucky to get seven weeks!

The NFL is a 17 week regular season with four poss playoff rounds, and I would be inclined to see 22-24 as the right benchmark for pro rugby players.

But yes, player welfare needs to be at the core of decision making and strong pa is part of that.

An outsider coming to the figures in those two squads would be hard pressed to discern the criteria…

I do feel a strong Players Association which is prepared to dive into the politics and fight its corner in negotiation with LNR/FFR is vital.

I don’t know whether those contracts would call for a certain number of appearances by the top players, but that would be a dangerous development. Players Associations are still in their infancy compared to the NFL but it is essential they have a strong say in their own welfare.

The Prem had its problems resolved for it eventually by financial difficulties which meant the RFU have a lot more say in player managment [dual contracts etc] but no sign of that happening across the channel with the French league in robust health.

So it’s wrong to try and play Test rugby without league matches running concurrently?

So it’s wrong to take a bespoke view of player welfare and try to reach the best outcome for all concerned?

Come back when you’ve got something constructive to say…

Ps how does a boy who grew up in Ulster and played for them end up looking at the world through blue tinted Leinster glasses?

It all sounds like corporate speak for “Last summer when we left them off the leash on tour, two got arrested for alleged sexual violence while another star player walked around the streets at 2 AM hunting down Arabs”.

“We’ve also missed all of our major financial targets following a home world cup which was run at a loss despite the promise of record revenue and we have dwindling numbers of young players coming through at grass roots.”

The test window was pushed back a few years ago to allow France to run off their Top14 and have adequate recovery time. France have gradually extended their domestic season.

It’s on them.

I doubt he’d have made it to a dozen caps in today’s game.

We don't need the opinions that are party-line repetitive, politely compliant, or predictably biased.

Bring on the independent thinkers and courageous voices.

Campo please stand your ground. You are enhancing your reputation.