1
'The Irish go a little too far' - Gibson-Park impresses French, to a point
By Ian Cameron
The French rugby press has lauded Ireland scrumhalf Jamieson Gibson-Park for his standout performances in Leinster’s recent Champions Cup victories over Leicester and La Rochelle – but warn against comparisons with the undisputed darling of Gallic rugby.
ADVERTISEMENT
While acknowledging Gibson-Park’s impact on the field – one writer hailing him as ‘the new boss of Leinster’ – they caution ‘the Irish’ against hyperbolic comparisons with France superstar Antoine Dupont. It’s simply a step too far.
The New Zealand-born scrum-half has indeed been pivotal in driving Leinster following the retirement of Johnny Sexton, adopting a halfback role more akin to the petit general role favoured by the French.
Nonetheless, French commentators suggest that equating Gibson-Park’s contributions to those of Dupont – widely regarded as one of the world’s best players in any position – might be an exaggeration. Sure, they respect Gibson-Park’s abilities; however, they insist clear distinction must be made between the 32-year-old and their messianic talisman.
“The Irish are surely going a little far when they consider Jamison Gibson-Park as the equal of Antoine Dupont,” wrote Midi Olympique Vincent Bissonnet. “We obviously won’t follow them to the end of their thoughts… However, we won’t push bad faith so far as to refuse to admit that Gibson-Park was excellent on the Aviva pitch, winning his duel against his compatriot Kerr-Barlow…”
The comparison has been made recently in the press, but it wasn’t an Irishman. Retired Wales captain Sam Warburton said of Gibson Park: “If Antoine Dupont wasn’t on this planet, then we’d be saying this guy’s the best No9 in the world by a mile.”
Gibson-Park has held the upper hand over Dupont in recent duels – or at least teams he’s been playing for have. Be it at Test level for Ireland against France or at club level against Toulouse for Leinster, the Great Barrier Island native has won his last four outings against Dupont.
ADVERTISEMENT
The pair could yet meet again in a Champions Cup final, should Leinster best Northampton at Croke Park and Toulouse make it past the tricky assignment of Harlequins. It’s one hell of a subplot.
So no Irish fan or journalist suggested JGP was as good as DuPont. Then even the guy who supposedly did is from Wales and said JGP would be the best around if it was t for DuPont. Right, so what is this story about again
Most articles (none Irish) said JGP might be second best globally (after Dupont).
Anyway, he is playing great. Different player but maybe he is equal to Dupont in how he is reading games now. He is also running a lot of Dupont support lines and scoring a lot of tries. Dupont is best scrum half but JGP in next pack.
Dupont wasn’t on the pitch when France last played Ireland.
Yes he was. He tackled Mack Hansen to stop a certain try.
Well you can say which scrumhalf is the best. But neither of them have made it to the Semi Finals of the RWC. We, South Africa, have four who helped us win the title. Just saying.
Yawn
Literally not a single newspaper article in Ireland has made this claim. Even Sam Warburton (who is Welsh), didn’t make any comparison. He literally said “If Antoine Dupont wasn’t on this planet” - in other words, if he didn’t exist - before putting JGP into the conversation of best scrum half.
Vincent Bissonnet seems to have got his knickers in a twist about something that he imagined might have been said by an imaginary Irish person who imagined that JGP was quite good at rugby!!
They’re trying to blend in with the southern hemisphere by getting outraged at someone for something somebody else said
Ireland are going to win the world cup 🥤
Whinging KiwiSteve is still crying over Ireland hammering NZ in NZ series.
Maybe with 4 more NZ backs?
Of course they are. Again.
New Zealand are going to win the world cup
Ah bless, still sorely losing after the 2022 series? Rent free etc.
Yes, when New Zealand and South Africa stop existing. But it's good to think positively. It keeps the action very interesting