Northern Edition
Select Edition
Northern Northern
Southern Southern
Global Global
New Zealand New Zealand
France France

Key battles won and lost: How The Red Roses secured NZ win

Ellie Kildunne of England during the WXV1 match between New Zealand Silver Ferns and England at Go Media Stadium Mt Smart on November 04, 2023 in Auckland, New Zealand. (Photo by Dave Rowland/Getty Images)

After 38 minutes that all went England’s way, a New Zealand try in the close of the first half signalled we still had a game on our hands. In the end the Red Roses would power to a 33-12 victory to take home the WXV 1 title.

ADVERTISEMENT

The Black Ferns’ two tries – either side of half time – gave them hope, but in the end the power of the English pack won through, their forwards combining for five tries and exerting their physical dominance.

Here’s where the Red Roses took advantage, and where the Black Ferns showed their class:

Front Row – Advantage England
The first half would see the Black Ferns really struggle at set piece, with a struggling lineout and a barely stable scrum. A change of front row on 45 minutes seemed to offer renewed stability for the hosts.
The Red Roses front row is always one of their most dangerous weapons. Sarah Bern continuously threated with barrelling runs while Lark Atkin-Davies scored a trademark try off the back of a maul and threw with pinpoint accuracy.

Second Row – Advantage England
Lineout dominance is the Red Roses bread and butter, but it’s the work England’s engine room put in around the park that should set them apart. Zoe Aldcroft quietly goes about her duties, racking up tackles and hitting every ruck (and also scoring a try), while RugbyPass columnist Rosie Galligan was an imperious presence, laying some big hits early on.
Chelsea Bremner was an absolute machine for the Black Ferns and a constant thorn in England’s side, but the stuttering New Zealand lineout is a black mark on the performance of their locks.

Back Row – Advantage England
Marlie Packer lead from the front with an imperious performance, crashing into black shirts time and again with no regard for her own wellbeing. Morwenna Talling continues to grow into the 6 shirt and with her power and eye for a break she could be a candidate to move out to 8 in the future. Alex Matthews, typically a blindside, has revelled in her role at the base of the scrum this tournament with some lovely runs and, today, the opening try.
The Black Ferns loose forwards are no slouches themselves. Liana Mikaele-Tu’u constantly threatened with her powerful presence and captain Kennedy Simon echoed her opposite number Packer with a performance that left nothing in reserve.

Half backs – Advantage New Zealand
Natasha Hunt’s return to the 9 shirt gave England some real buzz and she worked well with Holly Aitchison to open up some space for her Red Roses colleagues.
Across the park Ruahei Demant gave a masterclass in the modern fly-half. Superb distribution stretched the Red Roses line, she made some lovely breaks herself and in defence she absolutely refused to let a player pass her. A performance that underlined her nomination for World Player of the Year.

Centres – Advantage New Zealand
Sylvia Brunt and Amy du Plessis were imperious in the centre of the park for the Black Ferns, defending resolutely, getting patched up and going again.
Helena Rowland threatened for the Red Roses and Tatyana Heard grew into the game with some hard-running carries.

ADVERTISEMENT

Outside Backs – Advantage England
Two disallowed tries didn’t diminish Ellie Kildunne’s performance for the Red Roses. The full back looked like she might be a little lightweight for this New Zealand team after conceding ground twice in the opening minutes, but she seemed to take that as a personal slight and thereafter was a constant danger both with her own elusive running and her ability to bring her wingers into play, whether through a hard hitting Abby Dow run or a mazy dance through the defensive line from Claudia MacDonald.
Renee Holmes will be frustrated with her kicking in this game, but in open play she snuffed out many of England’s best attacking opportunities. Ruby Tui drew focus time and again and even chipped in with a few turnover attempts.

ADVERTISEMENT

Classic Wallabies vs British & Irish Legends | First Match | Full Match Replay

Did the Lions loosies get away with murder? And revisiting the Springboks lift | Whistle Watch

The First Test, Visiting The Great Barrier Reef & Poetry with Pierre | Ep 6: The Ultimate Test

KOKO Show | July 22nd | Full Throttle with Brisbane Test Review and Melbourne Preview

New Zealand v South Africa | World Rugby U20 Championship | Extended Highlights

USA vs England | Men's International | Full Match Replay

France v Argentina | World Rugby U20 Championship | Extended Highlights

Lions Share | Episode 4

Trending on RugbyPass

Comments

2 Comments
C
CN 627 days ago

It would seem everyone was imperious.

D
Derek 628 days ago

Well Done Red Roses

Join free and tell us what you really think!

Sign up for free
ADVERTISEMENT

Latest Features

Comments on RugbyPass

S
SC 2 hours ago
New All Blacks locks squeezing captain Barrett out of contention

As a former lock, it’s frustrating that most media and supporters do not know that there is a significant difference in the roles and duties (even body types) of a 4 power tight lock and 5 aerial loose lock.


The 4 lock is an enforcer who is very physical and carries hard in tight, a very effective nasty ruck cleaner, a very powerful scrummager behind the tighthead, and hard hitting defender. Often the are the second lineout option at the back. This is the spot Scott Barrett and Patrick Tuipulotu, Isaiah Walker- Leawere play. Big tough hard men. Think Bakkies Botha and Brodie Retallick.


The 5 lock is almost always taller and leaner as their primary responsibility is winning the ball in the air on lineouts and restarts. Height is essential. They clean a ton of rucks and make a lot of tackles but their carries tend to be out wider in space and which requires more athleticism than tight lock. This is where Holland, Va’ai, and Darry play. Think Victor Matfield and Sam Whitelock.


My point is Holland is way too lean in his body shape at this point, and too inexperienced, and not quite enough mongrel to play 4. Give him time to physically mature and harden up. He is playing great at 5 and Va’ai looks very good at 6.


And if Hamish believes that Tuipulotu has suddenly become a better tight lock at test level over Barrett based on two performances vs France B god bless him but I’ll base my decision over their career test form and even Super Rugby 2025 form where there is no question Barrett is superior. I do like Tuipulotu as a bench lock playing the last 20-25 minutes for Barrett with a 6-2 bench.

24 Go to comments
S
Soliloquin 2 hours ago
Competing interests and rotated squads: What the 'player welfare summer' is really telling us

I don’t know the financial story behind the changes that were implemented, but I guess clubs started to lose money, Mourad Boudjellal won it all with Toulon, got tired and wanted to invest in football , the French national team was at its lowest with the QF humiliation in 2015 and the FFR needed to transform the model where no French talent could thrive. Interestingly enough, the JIFF rule came in during the 2009/2010 season, so before the Toulon dynasty, but it was only 40% of the players that to be from trained in French academies. But the crops came a few years later, when they passed it at the current level of 70%.

Again, I’m not a huge fan of under 18 players being scouted and signed. I’d rather have French clubs create sub-academies in French territories like Wallis and Futuna, New Caledonia and other places that are culturally closer to RU and geographically closer to rugby lands. Mauvaka, Moefana, Taofifenua bros, Tolofua bros, Falatea - they all came to mainland after starting their rugby adventure back home.

They’re French, they come from economically struggling areas, and rugby can help locally, instead of lumping foreign talents.

And even though many national teams benefit from their players training and playing in France, there are cases where they could avoid trying to get them in the French national team (Tatafu).

In other cases, I feel less shame when the country doesn’t believe in the player like in Meafou’s case.

And there are players that never consider switching to the French national team like Niniashvili, Merckler or even Capuozzo, who is French and doesn’t really speak Italian.

We’ll see with Jacques Willis 🥲


But hey, it’s nothing new to Australia and NZ with PI!

109 Go to comments
LONG READ
LONG READ Harness Skelton's might and move Sua'ali'i: How the Wallabies can fix things for Test two Harness Skelton's might and move Sua'ali'i: How the Wallabies can fix things for Test two