1
Never mind the anti-rucking – we need to talk about penalty tries
By Jamie Wall
There's a grey area around the penalty try, and it's only going to get bigger, writes Jamie Wall.
How long until we see someone score a try they wish they hadn’t?
Specifically, when a team is under advantage for an offence that will lead to a penalty try, shouldn’t the ref just immediately award it regardless of whether the try is scored legitimately or not?
This isn’t about the ruling around why penalty tries are awarded. While usually pretty clear cut, they can also be controversial enough to be debated until the end of time. And, every, now and then, they can decide a match:
But let's say Cornal Hendricks had somehow managed to hang on to the ball and score in the corner. The Boks were down by six, meaning a sideline conversion was potentially crucial to the outcome of the game. Of course, with a penalty try, the kick is automatically moved under the posts -–a shot that any under-12’s player would be embarrassed to miss.
Over the weekend, a couple of incidents showed a major black hole in officiating common sense.
In Brisbane, a Sharks lineout drive against the Reds saw them score despite the maul being pulled down and being under a penalty try advantage. Pat Lambie did kick the conversion from about 10m away in from touch, however.
Meanwhile, in Edinburgh, Scottish winger Tommy Seymour dived over in the corner despite copping a high shot from Welsh second five Scott Williams, which would have been a textbook penalty under the new laws. Again, despite the ball being grounded inches away from the sideline, Finn Russell had no problem with the conversion.
The Sharks ultimately went on to lose their match, blowing an eight-point lead and having to watch Lambie miss a penalty that would’ve seen them win. Scotland ended up comfortable victors, so Russell’s conversion was academic in the end.
So let’s treat this as a warning. Especially since the problem has such an easy solution that actually doesn’t need any tweaking of the rules at all. Right now, World Rugby’s definition on advantage is applied states ‘The advantage must be clear and real. A mere opportunity to gain advantage is not enough. If the non-offending team does not gain an advantage, the referee blows the whistle and brings play back to the place of infringement.’
What could be more of an advantage than a try under the posts? Shouldn't refs, just use a bit of common sense and overrule whatever happens next?
Either that or, given the new law interpretation on high tackles and how often players get collared in the act of scoring, the situation is going to become more and more commonplace.
Trending on RugbyPass
2
Fissler Confidential: Prem club move to ringfence Test star
3
Bulls star Willie le Roux makes U-turn on club future
4
Israel Folau to make rugby return despite mid-week Lions disappointmen
5
Latest Comments
REACH OUT TO TECH CYBER FORCE RECOVERY FOR A GREAT JOB
WhatsApp +15617263697
Fine wine and crypto do not always blend well, especially after a few drinks. I learned this the hard way after a record harvest at my vineyard. Swirling an old Cabernet under the stars, I was a financial connoisseur, my $720,000 Bitcoin wallet aging well for future returns. But the next morning, with a hangover as intense as my Merlion, I realized I'd forgotten my wallet password. Even worse, my recovery phrase, which I'd written down in my wine cellar notebook, had vanished. My eager new assistant had tidied up, mistaking my scribbled security notes for wine tasting spillage, and donated the entire book to the recycling gods. I dove into the garbage cans like a desperate sommelier searching for a quality grape but came up with broken dreams and soggy cardboard. Panic set in faster than cork taint. I faced the bitter truth: my digital fortune was bottled up tighter than a corked bottle with no opener. I sank into denial, questioning whether my future vineyard expansion would now be reduced to selling boxed wine. I panicked, pored over industry publications, and came across a wine industry newsletter that mentioned Tech Cyber Force Recovery. Their slogan, something playful about "decanting lost crypto," seemed like a sign from God. I contacted them, half-expecting snobbery or skepticism. What I received instead were tech wizards who tackled my case with humor and precision. Their team labored over my case like veteran sommeliers dissecting terroir. They painstakingly reconstructed transaction flows, timestamp records, and subtle wallet behavior. It was as if I was watching wine connoisseurs sniff out hints of blackcurrant and oak, but with algorithms and blockchain forensics. Each day, they provided updates with the finesse of tasting notes. “We’re detecting progress, notes of potential access, hints of password recovery on the finish.” Their creativity lightened my anxiety, and ten days later, they uncorked my digital vault. When I saw my Bitcoin balance restored, I nearly opened a bottle of my best vintage at 9 AM. My assistant and I shared a hearty laugh; he's still working for me, but now he labels my ledgers with "DO NOT TOUCH" in bold. My wine business is thriving thanks to Tech Cyber Force Recovery, and I have a new rule: passwords before Pinot. Cheers to their genius!
Go to commentsWe have to move on from last week. The team did. Chay Fihaki is playing great.Noah Hotham and outside him TahaKemara , fantastic. Tom Christie , the ultimate unsung hero, as Matt Todd was.Crisian Lio-Willie andAntonio Shalfoon , returned and showed what we missed last week.
Go to comments