Northern Edition

Select Edition

Northern Northern
Southern Southern
Global Global
New Zealand New Zealand
France France

Nigel Owens: The red card that was missed in Six Nations round four

Referee Damon Murphy (centre) with Karl Dickson and Chris Busby in Rome (Photo by Timothy Rogers/Getty Images)

Seasoned Test referee Nigel Owens has claimed that a red card was missed in last weekend’s Guinness Six Nations round four match between Italy and Wales. Azzurri winger Pierre Bruno was yellow carded by Australian referee Damon Murphy early in the second half for a forearm into the neck of Wyn Jones, but Owens believed it should have been a red card.

ADVERTISEMENT

Murphy, who was refereeing only his second-ever Guinness Six Nations, reviewed the footage of the incident with TMO Joy Neville and assistants Karl Dickson and Chris Busby, and it was decided that the ball-carrying Bruno only merited a 10-minute stint in the sin bin, not missing nearly the entire second half at Stadio Olimpico.

Owens believed differently, though. Reviewing the incident on the latest episode of his Whistle Watch programme, he said: “A big talking point in Italy was the Bruno yellow card, should it have bene more?

Video Spacer
Video Spacer

“Now then, this is what you can’t do as a player when you have the ball you cannot lead with this forearm up against the neck or the head area of a player. Sometimes what happens is this, when you have the ball in the other arm protecting yourself or protecting the ball, players go into the contact so the elbow or the arm will usually be down here and as they go in in a strong position they then push away.

“If they go in legally and then push away and the arm comes up pushing away, then we don’t have any foul play.

Related

“When you come in and the elbow is already up and you make contact with the neck or the head area then you are leading with a forearm, there is contact to the head, it is dangerous play and it should be a red card. In this instance here, it should have been a red card against Bruno for the elbow up contact to the next and head area.”

Owens also discussed two other incidents from that Six Nations match in Italy, the aerial collision between Liam Williams and Alessandro Fusco, and the decision not to award a penalty try after Owen Williams tackled Juan Ignacio Brex in an offside position.

ADVERTISEMENT

“One decision that was a grey area or a 50/50 was the Liam Williams contest in the air, should it have resulted in a yellow card or even a penalty? Well, maybe it should have, maybe it shouldn’t have. This is a really tricky one. It all depends on your interpretation on how you see it at the time and it’s exactly what the referee saw – it was a fair contest and play on,” reckoned Owens.

As for the incident involving Williams which left Kieran Crowley furious that a Six Nations penalty try wasn’t awarded to Italy, Owens said: “Should Owen Williams have been for being offside tackling and then a probable or possible penalty try? Well, a lot of people are getting confused here. When a tackle takes place there is an offside line so that players arriving must arrive from their own side, from their own goal side.

“So if the ball was still in the tackle area Williams must retreat and come in from his own side because the ball was deemed to be in the tackle area, it means he was offside making the tackle so there is an offence, there is a penalty.

“The next question is if he hadn’t done that would it lead to a try probably being scored and if they would have probably scored then it becomes a penalty try and a yellow card. But even if there was no penalty try it still could have meant that Williams would have had a yellow card if the referee felt that the actions were cynical.”

ADVERTISEMENT

ADVERTISEMENT

LIVE

New Zealand vs Argentina

Kubota Spears vs Saitama Wild Knights | Japan Rugby League One 2024/25 | Full Match Replay

The gruelling reality behind one of the fastest sports in the world | The Report

Boks Office | Episode 40 | The Steven Kitshoff Special

Perry Baker in the house | HSBC Life on Tour | Los Angeles

O2 Inside Line: All In | Episode 6 | Le Crunch

The Unexpected Journey to USA 7s Glory | Aaron Cummings | Sevens Wonders

USA vs Japan | Full Match Replay

Yokohama Canon Eagles vs Shizuoka BlueRevs | Japan Rugby League One 2024/25 | Full Match Replay

Confidence knocks and finding your people | Flo Williams | Rugby Rising Locker Room

Tackling reasons for drop-out in sport | Zainab Alema | Rugby Rising Locker Room

Jet Lag: The biggest challenge facing international sports? | The Report

Trending on RugbyPass

Comments

0 Comments
Be the first to comment...

Join free and tell us what you really think!

Sign up for free
ADVERTISEMENT

Latest Features

Comments on RugbyPass

j
julianaguido769 7 minutes ago
Finn Russell enjoys his return to Scotland as Bath beat Edinburgh to reach final

Malware attack, those two words turned my life upside down. In just minutes, 40 ETH vanished from my crypto wallet, stolen by an attacker who used advanced tactics to cover their tracks. I was in shock. Years of savings, gone in an instant. I contacted several well-known cybersecurity and blockchain forensics firms, hoping someone could help. But each one gave me the same grim answer: “Sorry, it’s untraceable.” It felt like the end of the road until I found (TRUST GEEKS HACK EXPERT). Unlike the others, (TRUST GEEKS HACK EXPERT) didn’t brush me off or offer false hope. Instead, they calmly explained their approach: deep blockchain analytics, behavioral wallet tracking, and a few proprietary techniques they’ve developed from years of experience in the field. They weren’t just talking, they meant business.Within days, they began tracking the stolen ETH across a complex web of transactions. The attacker had used mixers, layered wallets, and decentralized exchanges, trying to erase their digital footprints. But (TRUST GEEKS HACK EXPERT) followed the flow, detecting patterns and linking wallets through subtle behaviors that most firms overlook. Their team’s understanding of the blockchain's transparent yet intricate nature was nothing short of incredible. Through tireless investigation and real-time tracking, (TRUST GEEKS HACK EXPERT) managed to recover 39 ETH. That’s right out of the 40 ETH that was stolen, they got back 39. I couldn’t believe it. After being told over and over that my funds were gone forever, (TRUST GEEKS HACK EXPERT) brought them back.What impressed me just as much as the recovery itself was their professionalism. They communicated clearly throughout the process, providing updates, timelines, and even helping me understand how the malware worked and how to secure my assets going forward. It wasn’t just a recovery it was an education.(TRUST GEEKS HACK EXPERT) isn’t just another name in the industry. They are in a league of their own when it comes to blockchain forensics and crypto asset recovery. for Assistance support team is available Website (https://trustgeekshackexpert.com/) (E m a i l : info@Trustgeekshackexpert. c o m) (TeleGram: Trustgeekshackexpert)

0 Go to comments
R
RedWarriors 1 hour ago
Why ‘the curse of the Bambino’ is still stronger than ever at Leinster

How you fare in tight EPCR matches may come down to what experience you have in tight matches. Leinster have a lot less competitive coming from the URC as a top14 team or indeed a Premiership team. They should be better at match management, but many of the weaknesses exploited by Northampton would surely have been shored up with more competitive matches in the lead up.


I disagree Ireland had as good a chance of any of winning the RWC 2023. Ireland were the only team in the top 4 that had to play a big team the week before the QF (Scotland were then ranked #5). As well as injuring both wingers this took a big dint out of potential preparation for the QF.

Obviously the ludicrous draw affected Ireland also (as well as France and Scotland).

I am sure Ireland would not have chosen NZ as the opposition to break our QF hoodooo. NZ were a team full of players with RWC semi final and winners medals. Ireland (like France) had a sum total of 0 knock out win caps on the team.

It was well remarked during the knock outs that if you had to play France the time to play them was the QF before they were up and running. Same applied to Ireland. Ireland get the QF hoodoo off their backs with a match against (Arg/Wal/Eng/Fiji) they become a much harder proposition for NZ in a semi particularly as the playing fieled would be level with NZ having to focus on a big match the week before as Ireland had to.

I can’t go on about how incompetent the RWC draw and scheduling has been basically since the inception of the tournament. Lets have a fair draw and see how the teams fare.

119 Go to comments
LONG READ
LONG READ Series triumph but ‘vitriol’ for Gatland: 2013 Lions tour of Australia recalled Series triumph but ‘vitriol’ for Gatland: 2013 Lions tour of Australia recalled
Search