1
'Maybe it’s more on the Irish side' - Gregor Townsend on Scotland-Ireland 'grudge'
By PA
Gregor Townsend dismissed any notion that Scotland versus Ireland has become a grudge match ahead of Sunday’s Guinness Six Nations showdown between the sides at Murrayfield.
ADVERTISEMENT
The Scots have lost each of their last 10 meetings against the Irish – including two World Cup pool-stage fixtures – in a run stretching back to February 2017.
A perception has developed that Ireland take particular delight from putting Townsend’s men in their place whenever they are deemed to be talking bullishly about their prospects of ending a hoodoo now spanning eight years.
Video Player is loading.
This is a modal window.
The Video Cloud video was not found.
Error Code: VIDEO_CLOUD_ERR_VIDEO_NOT_FOUND
Session ID: 2025-05-23:28ff372121177633f30fdbf4 Player Element ID: brightcove-embedded-video
Asked if he detected a more intense rivalry between the sides in recent times, the Scotland head coach said: “I don’t think there is. Well, if there is, it’s just the same as any other game where teams want to build up something to provide extra motivation.
“So maybe it’s more on the Irish side, or the Irish media side, that there’s this rivalry or needle to give them extra motivation on why they want to win again.
“Obviously they’ve won this fixture a number of times but we see this as a game where we respect Ireland a lot and admire what they’ve done over the last few years, but it doesn’t stand out as a needle game for us.”
Townsend – who took charge four months after Scotland’s last win over the Irish – insisted he will not be making a big play of trying to smash the hoodoo during his team-talks because he does not believe it is particularly relevant to most of the players in his squad.
ADVERTISEMENT
“I think you only lean into it once you’ve ended it,” he said. “Honestly, I think it’s not something that our players talk about, we talk about our recent experiences against Ireland and why we weren’t able to play our best or what they did, how it’s shaped us and how we play now.
“I don’t think any – well, maybe one or two – players have been here throughout the eight years. It’s more your recent experiences and our most recent experiences are last week’s game (against Italy) and the two training sessions we’ve had this week, that’s what fills the minds of the players as we go into the game.”
Townsend, whose side started with a 31-19 win at home to Italy, acknowledged Scotland are underdogs for Sunday’s match.
“Ireland are a top side and they have been for a number of years, clearly favourites for this game and looking to win three Six Nations in a row, which would be unprecedented,” he said.
ADVERTISEMENT
“All credit to them, they’ve worked hard to be one of the top teams in the world and they’ve kept that going over the last couple of years.”
Townsend has made three changes to his starting XV, with loosehead Rory Sutherland, back-rower Jack Dempsey and versatile back Tom Jordan replacing Pierre Schoeman, Jamie Ritchie and Stafford McDowall, all of whom drop to the bench.
“I think there are similarities with the three of them, which is the real energy that they bring, they’re quick players, they are in good form,” said Townsend of the trio added to his team.
“Jack was getting back to full fitness (after injury) and he’s now had three weeks training with us, a game and a half, one with the club and one at the weekend, so he’s good to go. He’s been a starter for us for the last few years.
“With Rory, I think Rory and Pierre have been competing really hard over the last few months for that starting jersey and I feel Rory has earned it, he brings a lot of speed, both in his kick-chase, his defence and his ball-carrying.
“With Tom, it was great to see him play in the 15 jersey for us in November, like he has done in the 10 jersey for Glasgow for a few years now, and he just brought that off the bench at 12 (against Italy last weekend), and 12 was probably his natural position.
“It was the position he played most of his rugby growing up, so I think all three deserve an opportunity to start.”
News, stats, live rugby and more! Download the new RugbyPass app on the App Store (iOS) and Google Play (Android) now!
Let’s be honest. Who doesn’t have a grudge with Ireland?
🐟
20 years ago nobody had a grudge with Ireland so we are making excellent progress.
Peter O'Mahony is starting, which is a great selection. Good in lineout, but also will be a warhorse and leader in a situation without Farrell. He will also annoy the f**k out of the Scots and test their discipline as well as increasing the enjoyment factor for viewers hopefully.
Scotland are going 6-2 compared to Ireland's 5-3. Risky, Townsend is going all in.
Exhibit Z: "We owe these F***ers one" Stuart Hogg as appeared on Full Contact Netflix 2023.
Exhibit A: Irish Team bus is sent a few times around the block in 2017. Ireland go 17-3 behind after no warm up. Final score 27-22 Scotland's last win.
O'Mahony and Russell were shouting at each other during RWC match.
Honestly no grudge between supporters who get on really well. Ive been at a few Edinburgh matches. Just good fun with supporters. Win lose or draw they have fun. England too. Welsh take it very seriously and dont hang around much after a defeat in Cardiff. At least that was the case. Maybe some needle with players. I like Scotland and they are on same trajectory as Ireland were. They are unlucky with two very good teams in their way now. Ireland won't give them this (I hope not), Scotland are going to have to go and win it.
Edit: Now that I remember: there was a bit of a big scuffle-more than handbags with Schoemann throwing Dan Sheehan over the hoarding in Stade De France?