No more time for testing - so what is the All Blacks' preferred midfield combination?

We’ve finally reached the last week of the year before the 2019 Rugby World Cup kicks off.
Super Rugby is out of the way, the Rugby Championship has come and gone and the All Blacks have played their final non-World Cup test of the year, against Tonga.
Still, however, New Zealanders can have little certainty over which midfield combination the All Blacks will roll out in their opening match against the Springboks.
It’s been an ongoing issue for the last four years. The All Blacks have access to a quintet of players that would likely make any team competing at the 2019 competition in the form of Sonny Bill Williams, Ryan Crotty, Anton Lienert-Brown, Jack Goodhue and Ngani Laumape.
In 2019, Ma’a Nonu emerged as a possible contender for a spot in the squad and Matt Proctor was given a token Test cap against Japan last year. A few other handy players also floated in and out of the squad in the early stages of the current World Cup cycle.
Needless to say, New Zealand is blessed with centres.
That being said, for all the talent that the All Blacks have at their disposal, an experienced, Test-forged combination has still yet to really be established in the midfield.
Plenty of options in the centres
Consider the following table, which shows how many times each combination of New Zealand’s centres has started in the four years since the 2015 World Cup.
Steve Hansen and his fellow selectors have always leaned towards the combo of Sonny Bill Williams and Ryan Crotty.
Williams is one of the most damaging ball-players the All Blacks have at their disposal; his offloading game is still second-to-none and even if he can’t get his hands free in the tackle, he always commands the attention of at least two defenders. Still, there are rumours that Williams’ place in the World Cup squad was dependant on a big game in the third Bledisloe Cup match of 2019.
Crotty is a safe bet; there are few players in New Zealand that are so good at making the right decision – even though he may not possess the outright skills or power of some of the other midfield options.
Can Ryan Crotty and Sonny Bill Williams keep it together?
Crotty and Williams have partnered up 12 times since 2015 – but nine of those games came during the 2017 season. Last year, the two paired up just three times and Crotty has only made one appearance in 2019 due to injury, in the recent fixture against Tonga. That game saw him partner with Anton Lienert-Brown.
Therein lies the problem with this combination: having both Williams and Crotty fit and ready to play.
Earlier today there was speculation that Williams would return home to New Zealand due to ongoing injury issues. He spent most of the Super Rugby season on the sidelines with various ailments.
Crotty has also spent the Test season to date playing the waiting game after injuring his hand in the Super Rugby finals.
Crotty earned his first Test cap of the year against Tonga and managed 66 minutes on the park. It’s been a similar story for Williams, who played for 58 minutes against South Africa and 65 minutes against Australia.
Impact sub or chance for elevation?
Outside the first-choice pairing of Williams and Crotty, the next most likely combinations both favour Anton Lienert-Brown, who has been Mr Fix-It for the All Blacks in recent times.
Lienert-Brown, like Crotty, is comfortable in both the 12 and 13 jerseys but has spent most of his time at outside centre for New Zealand.
Despite not being a part of a nailed down combination, Lienert-Brown has made a number of appearances alongside both Crotty and Williams. The Chiefs midfielder has also been the All Blacks’ go-to man off the bench, making 18 appearances off the pine over the last four years.
Lienert-Brown’s quick-stepping and sleight of hand have caused many a problem for tiring defences late in matches but there still seems to be the perception that he can’t get the most out of these skills earlier in games.
Continued below...
Still, Lienert-Brown always keeps the opposition guessing.
“He’s a bit unorthodox,” assistant coach Ian Foster said of Lienert-Brown after the latest Bledisloe Cup match.
“He doesn’t run lines that everyone else runs.”
That can make it a bit difficult for his teammates to run in support – but it also makes it very tough for opposing defences to set up against the former student of Christchurch Boys’ High School.
It’s Lienert-Brown’s all-round skillset that has seen him make 38 appearances for the All Blacks since his debut in 2016. That’s eight more matches than Crotty, who’s second on the list, and 18 more than Williams.
The Whangarei quick-riser
Jack Goodhue’s recent emergence has thrown a bit of a spanner in the works. Despite just a handful of caps to his name, Goodhue has looked unflustered on the international stage and there have been plenty of calls for the Northlander to usurp either Williams or Crotty in the starting line-up.
Goodhue debuted against France in June last year and played four matches on the trot – partnering Williams, Crotty and Ngani Laumape. He’s since also combined with Lienert-Brown in the starting midfield, but was only able to stay on the field for the first quarter of the match against Australia before suffering a hamstring injury.
Like Crotty and Williams, Goodhue has been somewhat unsighted on the international stage in 2019, clocking up just two games and only 98 minutes of play-time.
Wrecking-ball waiting in the wings
Ngani Laumape, the next cab off the ranks should injury strike the All Blacks’ current crop, has actually accrued more minutes for New Zealand in 2019 than three of the midfielders who are ranked ahead of him. The Hurricanes wrecking ball played the full match against Argentina and then came off the bench against Australia in the final two Bledisloe Cup games.
As a specialist 12, it was always going to be hard to fit the former League representative into the team, given the players available.
“It’s one of those positions where five doesn’t fit four,” said Steve Hansen at the All Blacks World Cup squad naming.
“Whoever we left out was going to be disappointed and probably deserved to be in the team.”
Still, with Crotty and Williams so injury-prone, it would not be a surprise to see Laumape called up to the squad before the tournament comes to a close.
Despite there being only a week until the All Blacks officially kick off their World Cup campaign, there’s still plenty of uncertainty surrounding the midfield.
There’s a long list of talented performers but there’s also a lack of proven combinations available – especially when compared to the last two World Cups where Ma’a Nonu and Conrad Smith suited up in the centres.
Do the All Blacks opt for the most established pairing of Sonny Bill Williams and Ryan Crotty until they succumb to inevitable injuries? Has Anton Lienert-Brown done enough to prove he should be starting for New Zealand, not just coming off the bench in the final quarter? Or could Jack Goodhue have catapulted his way into the side, despite having few caps to his name?
We’ll find out soon enough.
The All Blacks will be tackling Canada in the city of Oita next month - check out what's on offer once the sun goes down:
Latest Comments
“He won a ECL and a domestic treble at the beginning of his career.”
He won 2 ECLs at the beginning of his career (2009, 2011). Since then he’s won 1 in 15 years.
“He then won 3 leagues on the bounce later in his career”
He won 3 leagues on the bounce at the start of his career too - (2009, 2010, 2011).
If we’re judging him by champions league wins, he peaked in his late 30s, early 40s. If we’re judging him by domestic titles he’s stayed pretty consistent over his career. If we’re judging him by overall win rate he peaked at Bayern, and was better at Barcelona than at City. So no, he hasn’t gotten better by every measure.
“You mentioned coaches were older around the mid-2010’s compared to the mid-2000’s. Robson was well above the average age you’ve given for those periods even in the 90’s when in his pomp.”
Robson was 63-64 when he was at Barcelona, so he wasn’t very old. But yeah, he was slightly above the average age of 60 I gave for the top 4 premier league coaches in 2015, and quite a bit above the averages for 2005 and 2025.
“Also, comparing coaches - and their experiences, achievements - at different ages is unstable. It’s not a valid way to compare and tends to torpedo your own logic when you do compare them on equal terms. I can see why you don’t like doing it.”
Well my logic certainly hasn’t been torpedoed. Currently the most successful premier league coaches right now are younger than they were ten years ago. You can throw all the nuance at it that you want, but that fact won’t change. It’s not even clear what comparing managers “on equal terms” would even mean, or why it would be relevant to anything I’ve said.
“You still haven’t answered why Kiss could be a risker appointment?”
Because I’ve been talking to you about football managers. If you want to change the subject then great - I care a lot more about rugby than I do football.
But wrt Kiss, I don’t agree that 25 years experience is actually that useful, given what a different sport rugby was 25 years ago. Obviously in theory more experience can never be a bad thing, but I think 10 years of coaching experience is actually more than enough these days. Erasmus had been a coach for 13 years when he got the SA top job. Andy Farrell had been a coach for 9 when he got the Ireland job. I don’t think anyone would say that either of them were lacking in experience.
Now - what about coaches who do have 25+ years experience? The clearest example of that would be Eddie Jones, who started coaching 31 years ago. He did pretty well everywhere he worked until around 2021 (when he was 61), when results with England hit a sharp decline. He similarly oversaw a terrible run with Australia, and currently isn’t doing a great job with Japan.
Another example is Warren Gatland, who also started coaching full-time 31 years ago, after 5 years as a player-coach. Gatland did pretty well everywhere he went until 2020 (when he was 56), when he did a relatively poor job with the Chiefs, before doing a pretty poor job with the Lions, and then overseeing a genuine disaster with Wales. There are very few other examples, as most coaches retire or step back into lesser roles when they enter their 60s. Mick Byrne actually has 34 years experience in coaching (but only 23 years coaching in rugby) and at 66 he’s the oldest coach of a top 10 side, and he’s actually doing really well. He goes to show that you can continue to be a good coach well into your 60s, but he seems like an outlier.
So the point is - right now, Les Kiss looks like a pretty reliable option, but 5 years ago so did Eddie Jones and Warren Gatland before they went on to prove that coaches often decline as they get older. If Australia want Kiss as a short term appointment to take over after Schmidt leaves in the summer, I don’t think that would be a terrible idea - but NB wanted Kiss as a long term appointment starting in 2027! That’s a massive risk, given the chance that his aptitude will begin to decline.
Its kind of analagous to how players decline. We know (for example) that a fly-half can still be world class at 38, but we also know that most fly-halves peak in their mid-to-late 20s, so it is generally considered a risk to build your game plan around someone much older than that.
Go to commentsMy name is Alan Criner, and I'm a resident of Toronto, CA. I'm a 45-year-old financial analyst who has always been cautious with my investments. However, in my quest to diversify my portfolio, I fell prey to a devastating fake crypto investment scam, losing 125,000 Canadian dollars' worth of Bitcoin. This traumatic experience sent my life into a downward spiral, leaving me depressed and feeling hopeless.
Despite my repeated attempts to contact the account manager who initially approached me on Telegram, I was met with silence. They refused to provide any explanation or information, and I was locked out of my account on their website. The authorities were unable to assist me, as the scammers were untraceable.
Just when I thought all was lost, my nephew, a Canadian government lawyer, introduced me to Morphohack Cyber Service, a reputable private investigator and crypto recovery company. I visited their website (www . morphohackcyber . com) and, after mustering the courage, contacted them. They listened attentively as I recounted my ordeal and educated me on the scam, revealing that numerous others had fallen victim to the same scheme.
Although skeptical at first, I decided to take a chance. Morphohack guided me through the process, instructing me to set up a new wallet. To my astonishment, they successfully recovered my stolen Bitcoin and transferred it to my new wallet. I was stunned, struggling to comprehend how this was possible.
I initially wanted to keep this experience private, but I realized that there may be others out there who have suffered similar losses. If you're a victim of crypto theft, I urge you to reach out to Morphohack Cyber Service. They can be contacted through their website or email. (Morphohack@cyberservices . com, Info@morphohackcyber . com) Don't give up hope, there is a way to recover your stolen crypto assets.
Go to comments