Northern Edition
Select Edition
Northern Northern
Southern Southern
Global Global
New Zealand New Zealand
France France

Peter Bills: An Inconvenient Truth About English Rugby

Couldn’t even afford a photographer

News of record attendances and big TV deals masks an inconvenient truth about Premiership clubs, writes Peter Bills: most of them are skint.

ADVERTISEMENT

The party is in full swing up front and thousands are invited.

Only trouble is, there’s a lot of banging on the back door. Some guy calling himself the bailiff wants to come in and spoil the fun.

It’s a bit like that for most of the clubs in the Aviva Premiership. To put it bluntly, they’re living a lie. The bragging statements about record attendances, big TV deals and the like mask an inconvenient truth: a lot of them are skint.

Take the current English and European champions Saracens. You can’t get higher up the rugby pole than to conquer not just your own country but Europe too. Yet in 2015, Saracens’ debts soared beyond £40 million. According to figures filed at Companies House in London, Saracens’ now owe a cool £41.6 million.

OK, you say, that’s one club. But you’ll get bored if I trawl through a set of figures for everyone else in the Premiership. Let’s just look at Bath. The good news is, in the year to June 2015, their turnover grew to £14.6 million. The bad news? They made a loss of £1.8 million. Mind you, that was an improvement on the previous year when they lost £3 million.

Premiership rugby is awash with cash – on the surface. The RFU’s latest agreement with the clubs pledged funding worth more than £200 million over an 8-year period. A lucrative TV deal was signed with BT Sport for exclusive access (alas, it means millions of impressionable, potential young viewers only with access to terrestrial television are excluded from watching any English club rugby). And individual sponsors want to get on board.

[rugbypass-ad-banner id=”1475535264″]

So how on earth can clubs be losing money hand over fist? If you understand sport and know anything about professional football, you might remember a club named Leeds United. A few years after almost reaching a European Champions Cup final, they were stumbling to relegation and the verge of financial ruin.

ADVERTISEMENT

The reason? Leeds made the same mistake as English rugby clubs are now doing. They signed up stars on fabulous wages and thought the party would continue forever. Sadly, they learned the hard way.

Saracens are marching boldly down the same path. In a single season, their wage bill increased by an alarming £1 million. In fact, at one stage, their wage bill ballooned 50% in three years.

Now in a normal world, such figures would be unsustainable. What they tell us is that the club is spending way beyond its means. Its philosophy bears no relation to reality. If 60,000 people were pouring in to watch clubs such as Saracens play every home game, like Arsenal Football Club for instance, there would be no worries. But Saracens get tiny attendances by footballing standards.

Back in 1995, when rugby’s supposedly wise rulers burst open the door to professionalism, Saracens were then a club that played on a public park pitch at Southgate in North London. It wasn’t the nicest place. Dogs allowed to exercise on the fields fouled the rugby pitch and the wooden planks in the decrepit old stand were a hazard to any visiting bottom with their lethal splinters.

ADVERTISEMENT

Yet when rugby went professional, Saracens’ long-term supporter Nigel Wray talked about the possibility of professional rugby producing its own Manchester United. How 20 years have disabused Wray of that notion.

“Having been involved in professional rugby now for 20 years” Wray said recently, “I am constantly amazed at how hard it is to break into rugby’s culture.” His words came around the time Saracens admitted they had lost on average just over £5 million a year in each of the previous four years.

Seems like even as generous a benefactor as Wray is maybe now seeing the light. There aren’t going to be any Manchester United’s in the world of English professional rugby.

Just how have Saracens managed to go on being successful, signing expensive players and winning trophies? Purely by the loans handed to the club by men like Wray and a South African consortium of businessmen, allegedly including billionaire Johan Rupert.

All of which is very kind and very nice. But there’s one nasty fact behind this tale of generosity and largesse. The loans made are unsecured and the club’s parent company carry no legal obligation to service the debt.

That means they could walk away at any stage leaving the club insolvent.

And other clubs are in a similar predicament, completely reliant on a handful of wealthy benefactors. Better hope that party keeps going and the owners don’t get bored with it all

ADVERTISEMENT

KOKO Show | July 22nd | Full Throttle with Brisbane Test Review and Melbourne Preview

New Zealand v South Africa | World Rugby U20 Championship | Extended Highlights

USA vs England | Men's International | Full Match Replay

France v Argentina | World Rugby U20 Championship | Extended Highlights

Lions Share | Episode 4

Zimbabwe vs Namibia | Rugby Africa Cup Final | Full Match Replay

USA vs Fiji | Women's International | Full Match Replay

Tattoos & Rugby: Why are tattoos so popular with sportspeople? | Amber Schonert | Rugby Rising Locker Room Season 2

Trending on RugbyPass

Comments

0 Comments
Be the first to comment...

Join free and tell us what you really think!

Sign up for free
ADVERTISEMENT

Latest Features

Comments on RugbyPass

S
Soliloquin 10 minutes ago
Why New Zealand learned more from their July series than France

Hastoy was a good prospect before the 2023 RWC, he was the fly-half who led La Rochelle to the victory in the Champions Cup final in Dublin against Leinster.

But he made it to the squad only because Ntamack got his ACL.

He played against Uruguay, which a terribly poor game by the French side, and since then he declined a bit, alongside his club.

Under the pressure of Reus and West at 10, he regained some credit at the end of the season (among all a drop at the 81st minute of a game).

He’s quite good everywhere, but not outstanding.

He doesn’t have the nerves, the defense and the tactical brain of Ntamack, the leadership and the creativity of Ramos or the exceptional attacking skills of Jalibert.


I really hope that:

-Ntamack will get his knee back. The surgery went well. He wasn’t the most elusive player in the world, but he was capable of amazing rushes like the one against NZ in 2021 or the Brennus-winning try in 2023.

-Jalibert will continue to improve his defense. He started working hard since March (after his defensive disaster against England) with a XIII specialist, and I’ve seen great moments, especially against Ntamack in the SF of the Champions Cup. It’s never too late. And it would be a great signal for Galthié.

-Hastoy will build up his partnership with Le Garrec, that La Rochelle will start a new phase with them and Niniashvili, Alldritt, Atonio, Boudehent, Jegou, Bosmorin, Bourgarit, Nowell, Wardi, Daunivucu, Kaddouri, Pacôme…

229 Go to comments
TRENDING
TRENDING ‘Should have won by 30’: Campese slams Wallabies before second Lions Test ‘Should have won by 30’: Campese slams Wallabies before 2nd Lions Test