Phil Kearns backs Bernard Foley over Christian Lealiifano as Australia's No. 10
Former Wallabies captain Phil Kearns believes Bernard Foley shades Christian Lealiifano as the ideal Australian five-eighth at the Rugby World Cup and hopes a way can be found to restore the "Pooper" back row mix.
Kearns leaned towards what worked best at the 2015 tournament when assessing the tight selection calls coach Michael Cheika will have to make in Japan.
Foley was one of the tournament's best players as the Wallabies marched to the final at Twickenham four years ago, although some critics say he hasn't played as well since.
Lealiifano is seen as having his nose in front in the battle to wear No. 10 against Fiji in next week's opening pool game.
Boasting superior Super Rugby form than Foley, in a Brumbies team playing at a higher level than the Waratahs, Lealiifano ended three years out of the test scene with starts against Argentina and in both Bledisloe Cup showdowns.
He added a fluent dimension in the 47-26 win over the All Blacks in Perth but was guilty of basic errors in the following week's return 36-0 loss at Eden Park.
"It's great to have Christian back. He showed a really good performance but also an average performance," Kearns told AAP.
"When Bernard's on song, he's a very, very good 10 and very reliable, which is so important.
"I think the biggest issue isn't so much which one but who can be most consistently good?
"And I think your 10 is probably going to have to be playing six games or seven games at the tournament, so that consistency factor is critical."
Foley, who turned 30 on Sunday, wasn't at his best in general play and with his goal kicking in the previous day's 34-17 win over Samoa.
Cheika gave no hint of his preference for the playmaking role, saying "maybe there isn't a wrong choice" in several of his squad's most competitive positions.
Pocock shone on return from injury against the Samoans and Kearns wants to see him back in tandem with captain Michael Hooper, giving the Wallabies two world class breakdown exponents.
His biggest concern is whether Australia have an ideal third back-rower to complement them.
The other candidates are impressive rookie No.8 Isi Naisarani, the versatile Jack Dempsey or powerhouse blindside flanker Lukhan Salakaia-Loto, who has played every minute of all five tests this year.
"When you're talking about the best sixes and sevens in the world, Hooper and Pocock would get a mention," Kearns said.
"The work rate's phenomenal but if you've got those two, you need a tall back-rower as well and perhaps that's where we're lacking."
AAP
Latest Comments
End of the day it wasn't Fozzie that missed two vital kicks at goal. It wasn't Fozzie who tackled high. It also wasn't Fozzie who fired his two closest friends lol. Razor already did the same with Leon McDonald, so this is nothing against him. Also, wasn't Fozzie who came up with the lame excuse called Suzie, that basically damned them for the next 100 years. Mark my words, they will keep losing important Rugby World Cup games until they apologise for what they did in post 1995. Disgraceful.
Go to commentsI’m a Bristol fan and it’s been brilliant watching them play this season and huge credit to Lam for the philosophical and strategic buy-in he’s gotten from his players.
My concern - and as illustrated against Leinster, is how the Bristol approach will hold up through the wet and windy winter months when fast, free-flowing, 15-man rugby becomes harder to execute.
Squad depth - again, illustrated by the capitulation to Leinster when McGinty went off, is also something that might see performances drop over the second half of the season.
All that being said, If they can hold firm’ish then you expect them to be in the top 4 come the Spring.
Go to comments