Picking a form British & Irish Lions XV post-Autumn Nations Series
With the Autumn Nations Series wrapped up, we've picked a British & Irish Lions XV based purely on their form over the November Test window.
1. Andrew Porter
It may have been a more workmanlike than spectacular autumn for Porter, but he did well in trying conditions and wasn't to blame for any back-sliding at scrum time for Ireland. Pips Pierre Schoeman to the loosehead spot.
2. Dewi Lake
The lone Welshman in this selection but by no means a token one, Lake continues to be a standout in a team struggling to keep their head above water.
3. Zander Fagerson
Earned multiple scrum penalties during the autumn and impressed on both sides of the ball. The big Glasgow prop edges out England's Will Stuart to the tighthead.
4. Joe McCarthy
He's a real 120kg handful and showed that he can mix it with the world's best, even if his youthful exuberance got the better of him at times.
5. Maro Itoje
Many have accused Itoje of resting on his laurels in recent years for England but this November saw a return to form for the Saracens man. We've pushed him across the row to accommodate McCarthy at four. Beats out Scotland's Grant Gilchrist who had a fine November, one unfortunate yellow card aside.
6. Chandler Cunningham-South
Though England struggled, the 21-year-old emerged as a standout, cementing his place in the back row with his immense physicality. Also showcased his skillset with impressive tries against Australia. Beat Scotland's outstanding Josh Bayliss to the blindside berth.
7. Josh van der Flier
While it wasn't quite fireworks from the former World Player of the Year, he put his hand up whenever called upon by Ireland this Autumn Nations Series, scoring three tries in four matches. An honourable mention must go to Rory Darge and Sam Underhill.
8. Caelan Doris
Becoming Ireland captain hasn't stifled Doris, who had another outstanding Test window in green. An unbackable favourite now for the Lions No.8 jersey.
9. Jamieson Gibson-Park
He may not have been at his very best but he's still head and shoulders above any other halfback, with the exception of Tomos Williams whose Autumn Nations Series was cut short by injury.
10. Marcus Smith
A real toss-up between himself and Finn Russell, who didn't quite hit the heights in his two starts for Scotland. While far from perfect, Smith impressed in a stumbling England side. Sam Prendergast also deserves a mention as he arguably would have taken this slot had he started more than two matches.
11. Ollie Sleightholme
He may not have been a starter for England at the beginning of November, but Sleightholme made a statement as soon as he was called on from the bench against Australia. Four tries in three games. Honourable mention to Duhan van der Merwe.
12. Sione Tuipulotu
Coming out of the Autumn Nations Series in huge credit, Tuipulotu didn't let captaincy hinder his performances. A bottomless well of go-forward for Gregor Townsend's side and a big leadership presence to boot.
13. Huw Jones
Is Jones' unpredictable Test career finally levelling out? He broke records for linebreaks against Fiji and was solid against both the Boks and the Wallabies. Hat tip to Garry Ringrose, who was maybe Ireland's most impressive centre this November despite limited game time.
14. Darcy Graham
He might not be a British & Irish Lions shoo-in but he was electric this November. When fit there are few better finishers in the game. He gets the nod over the impressive Immanuel Feyi-Waboso, whose series was cut short.
15. Blair Kinghorn
With Hugo Keenan failing to hit the heights this autumn, the Toulouse man showed he's more than ready to make his British & Irish Lions bow next summer.
Latest Comments
Ashes to ashes
Dust to dust
Ireland you're done
Everyone has you sussed
Go to commentsI’m not fully convinced this was any sort of deliberate grand plan by SB, other than perhaps a masterful way (as it transpired) of dealing with injuries to a couple of key players in positions that lack high calibre alternatives in SB’s view. Losing Martin and Lawrence was disruptive to the team England ideally wanted and pretty likely both start if they had been able to. Ted Hill clearly isn’t fully trusted, despite being on the bench vs Scotland and Italy, and Slade may have had his day in light of an winger being drafted in to start as Test centre for the first time. Moving Earl to centre is worthwhile, in the right circumstances, as a proving exercise for future reference but it’s not the way to go against any of the top teams.
So they may well have added another page to their emergency playbook but I’m doubtful it was a genuine attempt at cutting edge innovation. More a case of necessity being the mother of invention that happened to suit the opposition on that given day. I guess we’ll know more in the Autumn but it won’t be until next year in Paris that the first real test of that set up would come against a heavy power team, IF it’s still in use ofc…
Go to comments