1
Rassie Erasmus suspended by World Rugby
By Ian Cameron
Springboks director of rugby Rassie Erasmus has been suspended by World Rugby after a string of Tweets over two weekends which focused on refereeing decisions during the first two rounds of the Autumn Nations Series.
ADVERTISEMENT
South Africa fell to a 30-26 defeat against the French in Marseille on Saturday, a game which featured a number of controversial moments, including two red cards being handed out by referee Wayne Barnes.
Erasmus, who has just finished a near year-long matchday ban for posting a video about referee Nic Berry’s performance in the first British & Irish Lions Test, again posted videos in the wake of his side’s loss to France, having also done so following defeat to Ireland a week earlier.
Today Erasmus Tweeted that accusations that his videos have led to threats against Wayne Barnes are ‘completely unfounded’ and he argued that his videos ‘were not aimed at the officials, but to our SA fans on what we should do better’.
RugbyPass understands that World Rugby have been in dialogue with SA Rugby and that following that process the decision has been made to suspend the DoR for two games.
A World Rugby statement reads: “World Rugby has reviewed the recent social media posts by SA Rugby Director of Rugby, Rassie Erasmus that relate to match officiating in the Autumn Nations Series.
“Match officials are the backbone of the sport and without them there is no game. World Rugby condemns any public criticism of match official selection, performance or integrity, which undermines their role, the trust-based coach/match officials feedback process and the values of integrity, respect, solidarity and discipline that are at the heart of the sport.
ADVERTISEMENT
“The behaviour of coaching staff and match officials are widely observed by fans, media and participants at every level, and such behaviours affect how the values are applied across the game.
“In addition, under the Match Officials Communication Framework, national teams have the ability to enter into a confidential feedback process, which is critical for success in a high-performance environment. The success of these communications relies on direct and honest feedback which is delivered and received in a confidential way.”
Erasmus is now banned for two matches.
“In line with the Framework, World Rugby has the ability to impose a sanction where a breach has occurred. Having considered the matter World Rugby has issued a two-match ban against Rassie Erasmus and accordingly he may not take part in any match day activity in relation to the two upcoming test matches that South Africa has against Italy on 19 November, 2022 and England on 26 November, 2022. The ban includes engagement with media and social media in relation to match officials.”
Rory is distorting the argument and possibly click baiting here. Ignore him guys. Some of his insults are typical of a minority here in NZ that like to stereotype South Africans in a negative sense. I hope he is just a Pom sticking up for his under fire countryman because if he is a kiwi he is being hypocritical. Here the outcry from New Zealand rugby, the media and the public following NZ's exit from RWC 2007 was way more intense. Wayne Barnes was once again the ref in the quarter final played in Cardiff where NZ lost 20-18 in another game v France - funny that - and missed the forward pass which together with a questionable carding of an AB player "cost them the match" - the words of NZRU chairman Jock Hobbs on a Radio NZ interview. Strange he wasn't sanctioned by World Rugby too?
Punters here took to Wikipedia and published a obituary stating Barnsie had been lynched after the game and in a typical kiwi way of taking the piss (pun intended) out of the situation an effigy of Barnes was set up in the restroom of a Queenstown {NZ} establishment.
Apart from RANTING, what solutions to the problem of poor officiating is Rassie proposing?
Does he want more referees on the field, more time for repeated video replays, maybe 4 or 15 hour games to make sure every single call is 100% correct? What's going to happen when a scrum collapses, is the referee able to make a call based on what's in front of them or should it go to video and be replayed over and over until the correct decision can be determined. Are you going to review every play in a game for offside? Well good luck with that. Rugby decisions are not always black and white but subjective calls - some will go your way and some will not.
I think we need less intervention rather than more - just let the game flow and enjoy it.
ZZZzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz! Rugby Union! World Rugby? The problem rugby union has is that a lot of players, coaches and the games governing officers are all suffering from macho egos and damaged brains. Bit like some world leaders at present. I'd rather go for a walk on Saturday afternoon these days than watch pumped jockstraps strutting about like fighting cocks on top of a midden. Get a CT scan. Good health, BillR
Only when England gets dodgy calls in the RWC quarter finals 2023 and gets sent back over the English Channel to watch the finals from the comfort of an arm chair will World Rugby decide to sharpen up their act!
Two wrongs don't make a right….
They don't argue the facts, only he did not follow process…
Wayne Barnes best rugby match official in the world🙄
The way this is going I rather watch some golf✍️
What has he been suspended from - ranting? Given that his year long ranting ban had no positive impact on his capacity to rant whatsoever I shouldn't think he'll be to bothered.
I’m a Kiwi & I think he maybe going a little over the top but the rules do need to change around the defensive team getting pinged after a maul! I didn’t see the game but a double movement is a penalty & the communication between ref & tmo was cut off apparently! You can’t blame the ref but how about the broadcasting from the French television? Is this a sign for the World Cup next year? Only show certain angles when it suits! It’s a win at all costs when the northern hemisphere with billions of $$ have to have a cup winner !
What more needs to be said?
World Rugby is a disgrace ! World Rugby is corrupt ! World Rugby is a NH old boys club ! World Rugby should immediately step down !
I hear Rassie is planning to do an extended video where he 100% supports the officials and fully agrees with every decision they make in a match but it has been delayed until well South Africa actually win a game.
World Rugby is a disgrace ! World Rugby is corrupt ! World Rugby is a NH old boys club ! World Rugby should immediately step down !
Yay
How many times does this dude needs to learn the same lesson?
So refs can just go on and make BLATANT mistakes??? EVERY SINGLE GAME & WE SHOULD TAKE IT ON THE CHIN?
GET REAL
What lesson is that? That it is very easy to manipulate WR to get what you want? Rassie WANTS to either get away with more than is legal or to be banned and play the persecuted hero. He's building a narrative of the whole world picking on SA and him being the poor victim who's just after a fair go. All this is to fire up his team to go to the World Cup willing to run through walls. It's not eccentric, it's calculated. He thinks he's being innovative to give his team an edge. I'm not completely sure I disagree with him, even if his methods are destructive and manipulative and I'd like to disagree with him.
And the referee's get paid for their mistakes, are not reprimanded by the organization and just carry on. Who says that they are not being paid, by you know who. It is not impossible if you think about that.
You seem to think that anybody can be a referee and that they don’t get scrutinized more vigorously than anybody else on the pitch.
I don't know who. Who do you think is funding this conspiracy?
Naughty boy honestly the IRB need to wake up an autocratic organisation run by old stnuc maybe the should focus on improving refereeing and refs being biased,We need more Nigel Owen type ref's rather than Barnes who is a big turd
Interesting to see the Nigel Owens criticism of the decision to only award NZ a yellow card in the womens RWC final. Was he correct? Absolutely. Did he come out on a social platform and state his opinion? Yes. Did he give criticism of a refereeing team and not get a ban? Of course! Where's the World Rugby consistency now?...
Maybe if the quality of refereeing was up to a decent standard there wouldn't be all this criticism. It's not just Rassie that feels this way, players , coaches and fans worldwide are tired from poor quality refereeing, especially when theres four referees and a ton of cameras and tech tracking everything.
yep for example elbow to Kolbe's throat in front of Barnes and on camera could not have been missed so one presumes they felt it did not warrant sanction or...
World Rugby is run by decrepit old men that have passed their sell by date. Need to get rugby men in, that know the game and manage accordingly. This bunch is useless and inconsistent.
Rassie Erasmus banned repeatedly for doing the same thing again and again seems pretty consistent to me.