21 - 18

Rugby 'snobbery' towards Fifa World Cup controversy is getting crucified online

10 Dec 2022

(Photo by Fu Tian/China News Service/VCG via Getty Images)

A social media post by a rugby website taking the high ground over a Fifa World Cup controversy has backfired and become the latest example of rugby’s perceived snobbery over other sports.

The dramatic Fifa World Cup quarter-final between Argentina and the Netherlands ended with a penalty shootout win to the South Americans, who were overly ecstatic with the result of the penalty shootout.

The Argentinians were famously photographed screaming at the Dutch players as they ran past to celebrate reaching the World Cup semi-final.

Rugby website ‘Planet Rugby’ shared the image claiming that the behaviour by the Argentinians would never be seen in rugby.

The post read: “Don’t say it, don’t say it, don’t say it… Wouldn’t happen in rugby” along with an image of the moment.

Don't say it
Don't say it
Don't say it…
😬 Wouldn't happen in rugby. https://t.co/hc9h4emvME
— Planet Rugby (@PlanetRugby) December 10, 2022

The post has backfired spectacularly however, with many fed up with the perpetual insistence by rugby that it is ‘different’ in a holier-than-thou sense.

Many Twitter users fired up to dispel the myth that rugby supporters can stand on a pedestal and continue to look down on other sports and continue to be self-righetous.

One user wrote: “This rubbish is medieval and has to stop” while another wrote “everything that is wrong with rugby”

Other users raised the fake blood scandal from Harlequins in the Premiership as evidence that rugby has a fair share of unsportsmanlike incidents. The overall response was overwhelming negative.

Do go on… https://t.co/R0C9p5NPej pic.twitter.com/b1rCLkT284
— Alan Ryan ✏️ (@Alotron) December 10, 2022

wouldn't happen in golf either it's because it's a different sport you freak https://t.co/Nx6wSQOb1D
— ??d?m (@adaamjb) December 10, 2022

Rugby snobbery… get a grip https://t.co/WCIhyEgndD
— TheWaspsGuy (@Wasps_Guy) December 10, 2022

Everything that’s wrong with rugby. https://t.co/WxnKv3cfz8
— Gareth Davies (@GD10) December 10, 2022

I love both football and rugby, and I have seen this happen so many times in rugby, as it should. Rugby needs to stop thinking it’s above football, it’s such an exhausting attitude. https://t.co/cMOKXtzOf9
— M (@MWT39_) December 10, 2022

Love rugby, both codes, but this rubbish is medieval & has to stop.
Rugby wants to be like football – which has gotten the Premiership into serious trouble financially – & look down on football at the same time.
That last bit originated in the classism that still pervades union https://t.co/e1CUe1AKgX
— Mike Finn (@mikefinnsports) December 10, 2022

https://t.co/1uCDDgEV84 pic.twitter.com/rsvIpHtcNP
— Squidge Rugby (@SquidgeRugby) December 10, 2022

Happens all the time in rugby. I wish rugby fans would stop this pretentious attitude they have towards other sports. https://t.co/hMhLqOlcyl
— 🇻🇮Black Phillip🇬🇩 (@JohniFlash) December 10, 2022

Comments

2 Comments

AC 939 days ago

I hate the rivalry between football and rugby union. I love both games for different reasons, both are great games. Admittedly the international game in rugby is more exciting to me while the club game in football is better than in rugby. Wish rugby union supporters and football supporters would just put their swords away. Now, rugby league on the other hand, is some weird nonsense I want no part of (jk)

Rodrigo 939 days ago

It happens all the time, even in Rugby.

What would not happen is a RWC quarterfinal between the Netherlands and Argentina...

Join free and tell us what you really think!

Latest Features

LONG READ

Mick Cleary: 'The Lions need some serious honesty about what's required to win a Test match'

The 'limp' win over the Waratahs raised serious questions about the tourists' readiness for a full-blooded Test series against the Wallabies.

LONG READ

Brendan Fanning: 'So far the tour on Australian soil has lacked jeopardy.'

Joe Schmidt is a master tactician and he will be watching every move of his close friend and rival Andy Farrell as the Tests approach

LONG READ

Jamison Gibson-Park profile: 'The shy kid’s voice can now be heard all across the rugby world.'

At 33, the Ireland and probable Lions Test starting scrum-half has matured into one of the world's best players

Comments on RugbyPass

BAZ 6 minutes ago

Scott Robertson weighs in on Will Jordan's possible position switch

Me too SC 👻

52 Go to comments

AllyOz 9 minutes ago

Has Quade Cooper solved a Lions riddle for Australia?

I think there is a choice that Carter Gordon may never play again. His move to Rugby League ended in injury.

107 Go to comments

AllyOz 10 minutes ago

Has Quade Cooper solved a Lions riddle for Australia?

Quade has a lot of very supportive fans, and also, in Australia (and definitely in NZ), there are those that do not like him as a player. I do think his coaches were responsible for him not getting a run when he was at his peak, Cheika didn’t appear to be a fan, giving him only one pool game in the World Cup (or very few chances anyway) but I think Quade also must have had issues in fitting in with coaches (or certain types of coaches). I also think there was a long period of his career where he played injured and was off his best. And he sat out a full season of SR to play club rugby rather than leave Queensland, when he fell out of favour with Thorn. He didn’t seem to settle in at Toulon, or the Melbourne Rebels really either and then he went to Kintetsu where he was in a team that was either bottom of the top grade or top of the next grade down, where, I imagine, it is difficult to get a feel of a players value to the national team. There are two (or more) sides to everyone of those stories.

I was in the group that probably was never a fan. I can’t really say why. When I look back on his highlight reel, there were moments of sheer brilliance and he took the Reds to a Championship win against the Crusader. But I guess I always viewed him as high risk and I am not sure that, prior to 2021, we ever saw his best. We had Foley as a long term 10 under Cheika, and also Matt Toomua and Christian Leilafano. Quade Cooper was easily the most skilful of any of those, but whether or not his own judgement or his ability/willingness to follow the coaches/teams plan was ever at the level of some of those other players, I am not sure. In some way I see him as a Finn Russell type, who doesn’t always appear to get along with some coaches but I am not sure it is always the coaches fault. I think Quade had the confidence that, if he thought he was right he would not be deterred from following that and I imagine some coaches (and not just bad ones) struggle with that if they are seeing different pictures from where they are watching.

I think he makes some good points. I really don’t understand the reluctance to pick James O’Connor and I think he makes a good point about changing coaches. I agree that there is a sameness to each of the 10s we have at the moment.

However, if we are talking about the last decade, we did have Michael Cheika as the coach from late 2014 to 2019 - so that is half the decade. Since then we have had 3 coaches in 6 years.

I do understand the charge about having lost our playing identity and I think he is right that we have perhaps fallen for the trick of trying to jump on the latest trend or copying what has been successful elsewhere and hoping that it works for us. But I am not sure how he personally would go as a coach. I see a bit of a similarity to Gregor Townsend personality wise but that is just a guess - Gregor has done OK.

I hope Quade doesn’t become the David Campese of his generation and getting involved in coaching might be a way to avoid that. It is interesting that he has written these articles in the Australian as they have been a bit anti-Rugby in Australia after they missed out on the broadcast rights.

107 Go to comments

BA 23 minutes ago

Scott Robertson weighs in on Will Jordan's possible position switch

Woo wee that boy is smoking it at the moment

52 Go to comments

Over the sideline 23 minutes ago

Former All Blacks pick their right wing for second France Test

Sadly the “natural centre" we used didn’t get the job done. Reiko's ability at 13 went up considerably without him doing a thing at centre.

33 Go to comments

Over the sideline 26 minutes ago

Former All Blacks pick their right wing for second France Test

Why? Best winger in the world and scores more from wing than 15. Seems pretty easy.