Scotland player ratings vs Italy - 2021 Six Nations
Scotland player ratings: Scotland responded from back-to-back defeats with a comfortable bonus point win over Italy, condemning the visitors to a 32nd consecutive Six Nations defeat in the process.
There were eight tries from Gregor Townsend’s side – two each for hooker Dave Cherry and his Edinburgh team-mate Duhan van der Merwe – as they recorded a record win over an Italian side who looked out of their depth at times.
Here’s how the Scotland players performed as they recorded their second win of the campaign.
SCOTLAND PLAYER RATINGS:
15. SEAN MAITLAND – 7
Some lovely touches in attack and not tested defensively before he headed off. A rare outing at fullback but one he can be pleased with.
14. DARCY GRAHAM – 8
A constant threat with ball in hand and always looking for work. Hammered by Monty Ioane in the first half but recovered well and offers himself close to the ruck.
13. HUW JONES – 9
Against a very limited Italian defence, a constant threat. More than 150m made with ball in hand shows just how dangerous he can be when he’s at his best, and a second try in as many weeks to go alongside.
12. SAM JOHNSON – 8
Provided valuable go-forward and provides a sharp link between the half-backs and Scotland’s danger men. Showed excellent power to shrug off Bigi and score his fourth international try.
11. DUHAN VAN DER MERWE – 9
A couple of tries, including excellent support of Price’s 60m break to score late on and take Scotland to a half century. Twelve defenders beaten – some of them with ease – and more than 200m made show how dangerous the Worcester-bound wing is.
10. STUART HOGG – 8
Drove Scotland’s attack on his first international start at stand-off. Goalkicking the only slight issue and will have been disappointed not to get a try of his own.
9. SCOTT STEELE – 8
Brought his club form to the international arena on his first Scotland start. Brought speed of service that allowed Scotland to attack seemingly at will, and took his try well.
1. RORY SUTHERLAND – 7
Has cemented himself as Scotland’s first choice on the loosehead and helped to get Scotland on the front foot in the first half.
2. DAVID CHERRY – 8
The Edinburgh hooker couldn’t have dreamed of a better first Test start. Two tries and a hugely improved lineout, plus six carries. Should be the starter next Friday in Paris on the evidence of this performance.
3. ZANDER FAGERSON – 7
Back from suspension and a good 50 minutes before he was removed. Undoubtedly Scotland’s first choice tightead and a powerful scrum performance.
4. SAM SKINNER – 8
Led the defensive effort well with eight tackles made on his first start since August 2019. Has been in good club form and showed Gregor Townsend what he can do on the international stage.
5. GRANT GILCHRIST – 7
A big improvement in the lineout and the former captain was at the forefront of that. Also offers himself as a link between forwards and backs regularly, while chipped in with six tackles and eight carries.
6. JAMIE RITCHIE – 8
A couple of silly penalties blotted his copybook but Ritchie lives on the edge at the breakdown, while he does a lot of Scotland’s dirty work.
7. HAMISH WATSON – 9
Another huge shift from the all-action back-row in a Man of the Match display. In his 65 minutes, the Edinburgh man made 21 carries for more than 100 metres.
8. MATT FAGERSON – 8
The campaign started with doubts over whether he was the answer for Scotland at number eight and he’s answered them throughout. Fourteen carries, largely in heavy traffic, for the workhorse Glasgow number eight.
Latest Comments
Mallia deserves 8 at least. Brains and skills for the comeback. Him, Garcia and Albornoz the core of The Pumas attack. Hope to see them in the 15s against France
Go to commentsYeah nar I pretty much agree with that sentiment, wasn't just about the lineout though.
Yeah, I think it's the future of SR, even TRC. Graham above just now posting about how good a night it was with a dbl header of ENGvSA and NZvFrance, and now I don't want to kick SA or Argentina out of TRC but it would be great if in this next of the woods 2 more top teams could come in to create more of these sort of nights (for rugby's appeal). Often Arg and SA and both travel here and you get those games but more often doesn't work out right.
Obviously a long way off but USA and Japan are the obvious two. First thing we need to do is get Eddie Jones kicked out of Japan so they can start improving again and then get a couple of US teams in SRP (even if one its just a US based and augmented Jaguares).
It will start off the whole conferences are crap debate again (which I will continue to argue vehemently against), but imagine a 6 team Pacific conference, Tokyo Sunwolves (drafted from Tokyo JRLO teams), Tokyo All Stars (made up of best remaining foreign players and overseas drafts), ALL Nihon (best of local non Tokyo based talent, inc China/Korea etc, with mainland Japan), a could of West Coast american franchises and perhaps a second self PI driven Hawai'i based team, or Jagaures. So I see a short NFL like 3 or 4 month comp as fitting best, maybe not even a full round, NZvAUSvPAC, all games taking place within a 6hr window. Model for NZ will definitely still require a competitive and funded NPC!
On the Crusaders, I liked last years ending with Grace on the bench (ovbiously form dependent but thats how it ended) and Lio-Willie at 8. I could have Blackadder trying to be a 7 but think balance will be used with him at 6 and Kellow as 7. Scott Barrett is an international 6 sized player. It is just NZ style/model that pushes him into the tight, I reckon he'd be a great loose player, and saders have Strange and Cahill as bigger players (plus that change could draw someone like Darry back). Same with Haig now, hes not grown yet but Barrett hight and been playing 6, now that the Highlanders have only chosen two locks he'll be playing lock, and that is going to change his growth trajectory massively, rather than seeing him grow like an International 6.
Go to comments