1
'So stupid' - Jack Nowell tweet divides opinion after latest Prem red card
By Ian Cameron
England winger Jack Nowell has divided opinion on Twitter after his take on the latest Gallagher Premiership red card, one of a litany of cards brandished at both club and Test level.
Again the red was produced following a clearout at a ruck, with Exeter Chiefs' hooker Jack Yeandle getting sent off by referee Karl Dickson for a questionable entry to a breakdown. Dickson decided that there wasn't sufficient use of the arms - and together with a head-high contact to the Sale Sharks player - felt he had no choice to send the frontrower from the field after a TMO review.
It's the latest red card in elite rugby, with five handed out last weekend in the Gallagher Premiership alone, and two game-changing reds in the Guinness Six Nations for Ireland's Peter O'Mahony and Scotland Peter O'Mahony respectively.
Nowell, who is currently sidelined with an injury, took to Twitter to vent his frustration with the decision: "Seriously, all for players safety but come on. Some of these reds are so stupid. Every player takes the field knowing there is a chance of being hurt, it’s a physical game. Don’t kill it."
Fellow professional player Dan Mugford was in full agreement: "That is a ridiculous decision! Games gone! Illegal player, off feet in the breakdown, moving, completely accidental. GAME HAS GONE!
"I can almost guarantee if you watched every breakdown and reviewed, you’d find a penalty, not to mention the amounts of shoulders/arms to the head. So if you’re going to call it once, call it every time!
"Also I understand media/the game wanting to protect players heads. Make the game more inclusive etc. But part of the game is at times, you will put your head into a place where it could get hit. Same way as a boxer walks into the ring knowing he may take a knock to the head."
Many agreed with his tweet judging by the amount it garnered, while others attempted to argue the point. Rugby journalist and commentator Nick Heath wrote: "My take is that the focus on safety means that players need to just unlearn that ruck-hitting instinct.
"If the contest is lost, it's lost and people should resist that (potentially dangerous) clear out. Not likely to improve overnight but hopefully in time it will."
The inevitability of more reds cards in the professional game means this debate is set to run and run.
Trending on RugbyPass
2
All Blacks player ratings vs Italy
3
South Africa player ratings | 2024 Autumn Nations Series
4
Scotland's Sione Tuipulotu admits anger at Australian rugby
5
Latest Comments
Agreed. And I don't have much more to say on it, but I had been having one thought that sprang to mind at the tail of this discussion, and that is that it's not all about Razor.
It's not about any coach being "right". I think a lot of selections can become defense and while it doesn't really apply here I really enjoyed that Andy Farrell just gave into the public demands and changed out his team for the change that had been asked for. Like why not? This is the countries team, keep them engaged. The whole reason i've only just finished watching the game was because I wasn't interested in watching any of the selected players against a team like Italy (still actually enjoyed the first half with the contest Italy made of it).
Faz leap frogs a younger half back into start. He hands the golden child the game over July's golden child. He gives an old winger a go, a new flanker and hooker. None of them really did any good, certainly not enough to suggest they should have been promoted above others, but who cares? You won, and you gave the country what they wanted, that's all that matters after all. It's for the country, not the one in charge who thinks they have to have their own pied piper tune playing.
Go to commentsAs Naas would say... A win is a win.
It was not perfect and at times frustrating. All 3 tests were not the best by the Boks and they still found ways to win.
Rassie would have noted the sloppyness at times and silly mistakes. The 9's made amateur handling mistakes when clearing the rucks in all 3 tests.
Once the "stupid" mistakes are eliminated, this Bok team will be very very hard to beat.
Go to comments