1
'Stunned' Welsh great slams the radically changed Springboks XV
By PA
Gareth Edwards believes Wales have been disrespected by world champions South Africa over the Springboks’ second Test team selection. Head coach Jacques Nienaber has made 14 changes from the line-up that edged past Wales 32-29 in a thrilling series opener decided by Damian Willemse’s penalty with the game’s final kick.
ADVERTISEMENT
He has named two uncapped players in the starting XV – wing Kurt-Lee Arendse and number eight Evan Roos – and four more among the replacements. Only lock Eben Etzebeth remains from Pretoria, with Nienaber stating that he “needed to strike a balance between giving our talented young players an opportunity to show what they can do at international level and winning”.
Nienaber’s line-up contains a total of 393 caps, but 321 of those Test appearances are shared by just five players in Etzebeth, fly-half Handre Pollard, centre Jesse Kriel, prop Trevor Nyakane and flanker Pieter-Steph du Toit. Such an approach by the Springboks has cut little ice with Wales great Edwards, who also feels the clash in Bloemfontein on Saturday has been partly devalued.
Video Player is loading.
This is a modal window.
The Video Cloud video was not found.
Error Code: VIDEO_CLOUD_ERR_VIDEO_NOT_FOUND
Session ID: 2025-05-18:767359c455ba31e54c74e4f Player Element ID: brightcove-embedded-video
“The big disappointment for me was to learn South Africa are going to change virtually their whole team,” Edwards said. “They have got every right to prepare for the World Cup, but I would really like to know what their logic is in changing so many.
“I suppose the only way they can justify it is if they win. I think it shows a little bit of disrespect. If there had been five or six changes, you would maybe have raised an eyebrow. But 14 changes, it’s overwhelming.
“I don’t think it shows respect for Wales and, looking logically, there is only one way (for Wales) to view it and that is to give them a good ‘tonking’, as they say. It is a great opportunity to beat them and say, ‘Thank you very much for picking that team’. I’m not going to suggest for one minute that I know all that is right and wrong about the modern game, except that it is a pretty physically demanding set-up and it is important that you do (make changes), but there are ways and means of changing.
“It has stunned a lot of people. They [the Wales players] are probably talking to each other and saying, ‘Right boys, that’s what they think of us’. It’s great motivation for Wales. It [South Africa’s team selection] does to an extent (devalues the game). There is a lot at stake, but it takes a bit of an edge out of it. That is not Wales’ fault.”
ADVERTISEMENT
Wales have never defeated the Springboks in South Africa but after going desperately close at Loftus Versfeld last weekend, they will line up in Bloemfontein with a serious chance of making history. Unlike Nienaber, Wales boss Wayne Pivac is not expected to make wholesale alterations, although it is thought that wing Alex Cuthbert and hooker Dewi Lake are pushing hard for starts.
“Take it from me, any side I’ve played against in a green and gold jersey, you are going to have to give respect to. It is not going to be easy, far from it, second-team or not. My warning is don’t treat it lightly – treat it like it is the same (Springboks) team,” added Edwards.
Edwards, meanwhile, has received a lasting image of what is widely acclaimed as rugby union’s greatest try. Edwards’ score for the Barbarians against New Zealand at Cardiff Arms Park in January 1973 has long entered sporting folklore but amazingly there are no recorded photographs, with only television footage available to showcase a breath-taking length-of-the-field move started by Phil Bennett and finished by Edwards.
To mark Edwards’ 75th birthday next week, a painting by Welsh artist Elin Sian Blake was commissioned that captures him diving for the line. The Greatest Try project will include prints of it being sold for charity, with a celebration lunch planned at Celtic Manor Resort next January on the game’s 50th anniversary.
ADVERTISEMENT
Gareth Edwards should remember the 1998 Welsh tour to SA when 13 of their first choice players refused to tour because their coach had resigned shortly before the tour started and they did not like the interim coach. The result was a 98 point hiding by the springboks. Mr Edwards glass houses.
So he is effectively saying the springbok team for the 2nd test is not a quality team. I wonder who is disrespectful. The guy must have balls to say that. Let's see what will happen.
I feel that any coach has the right to pick any players he/she want's to. Rugby is played on the field and not the Pavillion.
Great man and Rugby player Garath Edwards. I dont agree with him that SA is disrespecting Wales. Currently we have great depth and quality and fielding them is not fielding second rate players. Saterday will reveal all so i look forward to a great game. I wish Garath all the very best for his 75th birthday.
Well, I'll say that I was really surprised by the amount of changes to the Bokke..........and actually quite nervous for Saturday. I understand they want to try and test new players before building for the World Cup............but that pick seems a bit crazy. Could he not have left such drastic measures for the last Test IF we already secured the series? Shouldn't that be the first priority? To secure/win the series? And then try keep the no-loss-in-SA-against-Wales intact, even though experimenting with loads new players?
Well Faf, I for one am happy that you're being "rested" this weekend because you had a SHOCKER last week. Very cool of you to comment and visit these boards regardless.
Another Rugby Pass non story.
Mr Edwards played in the amateur, pre-rwc era, and is apparently a bit too precious about Welsh rugby. Lets see what he says when Wales lose on Saturday.