Wales great Edwards urges Howley to unleash Giles
Gareth Edwards believes the time is right for Wales to unleash teenage wing Keelan Giles on Scotland in the Six Nations but said criticism of Alex Cuthbert is "unfair".
Giles has been billed as the 'new Shane Williams' after bursting onto the scene with some eye-catching displays for Ospreys this season.
The rapid 19-year-old missed out on a place in Rob Howley's squad for the start of the Six Nations after suffering a hamstring injury, but will make his Pro12 comeback against Munster in a top-of-the-table clash on Saturday.
Wales and British and Irish Lions legend Edwards wants Howley to hand the promising flyer his international debut at Murrayfield a week on Saturday.
Speaking on behalf of Land Rover, a Principal Partner of the British & Irish Lions, Edwards told Omnisport: "He's [Giles] a very, very good talent.
"I think maybe the Scotland game will be a good one to make his debut. There was a lot riding on the England game, not that I'm saying that the boy isn't capable, but I think it might well be an easier baptism for him to get into the Scottish game.
"That's not taking anything away from Scotland, I just think the intensity of facing England, and with Wales very much capable of winning the Grand Slam before that game, it was important that they kept all the experience they had.
"If they do change it and give him the opportunity, I'm sure the boy is quite capable of taking his chance. He's an extremely good wing."
Cuthbert came into the side with George North [dead leg] ruled out last Saturday and came under fire after he Elliot Daly outpaced him to score a decisive late try, which Owen Farrell converted expertly to seal a dramatic victory for England.
But Edwards said: "It seems unfair to single anybody out like that, he's been struggling a little bit with his form having been outstanding a couple of years ago.
"Nobody goes out on the field not to do his very best. I'm sympathetic, also because I'm a Cardiff Blues director, but you can point the finger to five or 10 minutes before that [Daly try] when we lost a lineout that created the opportunity for England. I don't think it's right to single anyone out on just that moment."
- Land Rover is on the hunt for grassroots Lions to join them on the British & Irish Lions Tour to New Zealand 2017. For your chance to win a place on tour, go to @LandRoverRugby #WeDealInReal
Latest Comments
"fl's idea, if I can speak for him to speed things up, was for it to be semifinalists first, Champions Cup (any that somehow didn't make a league semi), then Challenge's semi finalists (which would most certainly have been outside their league semi's you'd think), then perhaps the quarter finalists of each in the same manner. I don't think he was suggesting whoever next performed best in Europe but didn't make those knockouts (like those round of 16 losers), I doubt that would ever happen."
That's not quite my idea.
For a 20 team champions cup I'd have 4 teams qualify from the previous years champions cup, and 4 from the previous years challenge cup. For a 16 team champions cup I'd have 3 teams qualify from the previous years champions cup, and 1 from the previous years challenge cup.
"The problem I mainly saw with his idea (much the same as you see, that league finish is a better indicator) is that you could have one of the best candidates lose in the quarters to the eventual champions, and so miss out for someone who got an easier ride, and also finished lower in the league, perhaps in their own league, and who you beat everytime."
If teams get a tough draw in the challenge cup quarters, they should have won more pool games and so got better seeding. My system is less about finding the best teams, and more about finding the teams who perform at the highest level in european competition.
Go to commentsWalter has been permanently psychologically damaged since his wife left him and moved in with a man from Sydney.
Go to comments