1
'We expected better': Ex-All Black disappoints in first start in France
By Ben Smith
Former All Blacks halfback Brad Weber has disappointed in his starting debut for Stade Francais in a lopsided 30-6 loss to Pau in the Top 14.
After two showings off the bench to start his stint in France with the Paris club, the former Chiefs co-captain started in the round eight clash.
Stade fell behind early as Pau put in two tries through blindside Sacha Zegueur and lock Mickael Capelli.
Former Exeter flyhalf Joe Simmonds kicked two conversions and two penalties to give Pau a 20-6 lead at half-time.
Stade Francais remained scoreless in the second half as Simmonds added another penalty and former All Black No 8 Luke Whitelock added another Pau try.
Weber and former England international Joe Marchant, who had a stint with the Blues in Super Rugby in 2019, were rated "flops" by French writer Jerome Prevot of RugbyRama.
On the All Blacks No 9 he was at a lost for words for Weber's showing that was "without genius".
"What to say? Otherwise, we expected better from this New Zealand scrum-half, 18 times selected for the All Blacks," he wrote.
"Few differences on personal initiatives, few decisive gestures and this incomprehensible decision on a penalty which he played quickly to immediately hit directly into touch.
On Marchant he wrote that he was "annihilated" from "start to finish" by the Pau defence.
The England midfielder had seven carries for seven metres and one turnover conceded.
"It wasn't the kind of match that could have made him shine naturally. So, we expected from the center of the XV de la Rose, something more incisive, something that would have some allure.
"We felt him annihilated by the Pau defense almost from start to finish."
Weber didn't fare much better taking six runs for 15 metres as he tried to get his running game going.
Stade Francais failed to register a line break as the Pau defence proved unbreakable.
The clash was a crunch game between two of the top four sides in the Top 14 with Pau now leading the league in first.
After the loss, Stade Francais slipped to 5-3 on the season and remain in third place, a reversal of the positions they held going into the match.
Trending on RugbyPass
2
South Africa vs England player ratings | 2024 Autumn Nations Series
3
All Blacks player ratings vs France
4
Netherlands serve up Tier 2 shock as another World Cup side slayed
5
Latest Comments
Paddy T is playing the best footy of his career off the bench, and he’s a leader.
Straight swap: Paddy in for Scott, Scott to the bench.
But I’m loving Tuipolotu as an impact sub.
Go to commentsWhats that team then? Are Clarke or Tele'a likely to come back? Proctor didn't return to the squad did he?
I'd like see the young fullbacks play fullback, and so Jordan cover on the wing instead. Even seeing Reiks on the other wing would be cool, Reece can go back on the bench if theres even room for him there.
So preferably it would be ALB and second five where he came of the bench in the weekend and was great. He's a bit slow on the play for outside center but looks like he might need to play there if we need wingers.
Cane really sounds like he'll bit fit, is he going to want to play? I'd really like to see Kirifi earn a cap if Lakai was the only 7 (Ardie has to be all used up/finished for the year). Which young lock are we going to see come in?
No team lists here, that's kid games...
Go to comments