Select Edition

Select Edition

Northern
Southern
Global
NZ
France
InternationalTongaJeff Wilson

Why All Blacks legend was 'uncomfortable' about Steve Hansen's 14-man Tonga tactic

By Online Editors
Steve Hansen with All Blacks captain Kieran Read. (Photo by Hannah Peters/Getty Images)

NZ Herald

All Blacks legend Jeff Wilson wasn't the biggest fan of Steve Hansen's decision to finish the final few minutes of their game against Tonga with 14 men.

Hansen explained last week that he deliberately forced his side to finish their 92-7 thrashing of Tonga with 14 players in the final 15 or so minutes of the match in order to put more pressure on them.

"We ran out of reserves and Ryan only needed to play for 65 minutes on his return," Hansen said.

When asked whether it was in preparation for a yellow or red card at the upcoming World Cup, he replied: "We have plenty of those tests anyway and we don't need too many more of them.

"Obviously his (Crotty's) welfare was more important and it was a good opportunity again to put ourselves under a bit of pressure when it comes to how many we have on the park.

"We had to make that choice and the score told us we could make that choice with relatively low risk."

Some fans and pundits argued that the move was perhaps slightly "arrogant", with Fox Sports Australia asking the question which was on the minds of some after the match – were the All Blacks "arrogant or just plain smart?" – while Wales Online called it an "interesting decision".

Speaking to Radio Sport, Wilson said he understood why the All Blacks decided to play with 14 men on purpose, but admitted that he was "a little uncomfortable with it".

"They had a plan and I don't know if this was always the plan but the fact that they exhausted all their options, they could've put someone back out there but then they would've reshuffled," Wilson said.

"There was an unnecessary risk in terms of players so why do it. I get that, having a guy who's gone off and cooled down a little bit. It did present them with an opportunity to play with 14 men.

"Look I had my doubts at the time whether or not I really wanted to see that happen. But I can see why they did it. I'm not going to bag them for it. I think that was the decision that was made. And it just showed the difference that it made – they didn't score for those 14 minutes.

"It just shows how significant those moments when you could get down to 14 men are. And the fact that Tonga were good enough to go 'you know what this is our opportunity, we're going to take it'. I was a little uncomfortable with it but can understand it."

The All Blacks flew out for Japan this morning ahead of their first match of the Rugby World Cup against the Springboks on September 21.

This article first appeared on nzherald.co.nz and was republished with permission.

In other news:

Trending on RugbyPass

1

All Blacks player ratings vs Italy

2

South Africa player ratings | 2024 Autumn Nations Series

3

Scotland's Sione Tuipulotu admits anger at Australian rugby

4

Fissler Confidential: Willie le Roux rumours ignite after Bok star spo

5

English club target Liam Williams for Premiership return

More News

Latest Comments

All Blacks player ratings vs Italy | Autumn Nations Series
C
Cantab 17 minutes ago

Yes Roigard scored a great try when the Italians were focusing on our mediocre midfield which defends well enough but has lacked penetration all year. We could certainly do with the likes of a Nonu or Robertson from yesteryear who did know how to penetrate in midfield. A work on for Razor next year as I have seen some promising talent at provincial and super franchise levels which needs to be developed.

Go to comments
TJ Perenara clarifies reference to the Treaty in All Blacks' Haka
S
SadersMan 42 minutes ago

Yeah, I'm down with unity.


E pai ana o korero TJ.

Go to comments