Will Mathieu Raynal be the star of the show in the first Bledisloe test?

Who’ll be the star of the show at Marvel Stadium on Thursday?
Will it be Rieko Ioane? Captain Fantastic Sam Cane? Marika Koroibete or Rob Valetini?
Sadly, as we’ve become increasingly accustomed, it might well be referee Mathieu Raynal.
I don’t seek to blame referees for rugby’s ills.
After all, it’s an incredibly thankless task.
I was at a schoolboy match the other day, where a spectator found fault with a parent-referee’s decision.
The ref stopped the game to ask the spectator if he’d like to come out on the field and do it himself. I can’t quote what the referee said but, when the spectator replied “no,’’ the ref told him to shut the front door, or words to that effect.
It’s easy to dismiss Wallabies great David Campese. The man has a lot to say about rugby and rarely is any of it good.
But Campese was right in taking the game to task last week and for trying to speak on behalf of disgruntled and bewildered fans.
Rugby has so many laws, seemingly all of them open to interpretation, which contribute to making the sport stop-start at best.
From scrums, to the breakdown, lineouts, mauls and incidental contact with the head, referees aren’t short of areas in which to intervene.
I was disappointed, as a fan of rugby, with the way Nic Berry refereed the recent match between New Zealand and Argentina. The Pumas were probably never a chance of upsetting the All Blacks two weeks in a row, but I didn’t feel Berry even allowed them the opportunity to make it a contest.
Similarly, Ben O’Keeffe played way too big a part in South Africa’s win over Australia that same evening.
Refereeing is incredibly hard, not least because of all the audio the man in the middle gets in his ear. Georgian Nika Amashukeli copped a bit of grief for the way he controlled the All Blacks and Pumas in Christchurch, but I’d contend it was the Television Match Official and Assistant Referees who ran that match.
Amashukeli was guilty of over-explaining decisions that night, I suspect in part because often he wasn’t the one making them.
Look, I just want the ball in play and for the two teams to decide the outcome. If a few scrums hit the deck and the breakdowns are a shambles, so be it.
I’m tired of scrum re-sets and referees guessing which prop to penalise for a collapse. I get no satisfaction from hearing the whistle blow every time a ball-runner hits the deck.
I can’t believe we’re having official water breaks in test matches, when guys in bibs are bringing bottles on every couple of minutes as it is.
Rugby’s not alone there. There isn’t a round of the English Premier League that passes without comment on the inadequacy of the VAR system.
The NRL’s Bunker has made that sport almost as stop-start as rugby and cricket’s DRS wastes minutes analysing incidents that should take seconds.
The search for a perfect game, a game without error or controversy or anything to frighten the mothers of would-be players has spoiled a good product.
It has given officials - both on and off the field - licence to nitpick and interfere. Too often the whistle blows and no-one, be they player, coach, spectator or commentator knows why or who’s at fault.
It’s not always that way. I thought Angus Gardiner was in total command, when South Africa beat the All Blacks at Mbombela Stadium.
It was clear he had the TMO and ARs in his ear the whole time, but he ran the show. He let the game flow and he ignored the attempts of the other officials to overrule him.
But that’s the exception, as far as I can tell.
I hope Thursday’s test in Melbourne is a contest. I hope the ball’s in play, both teams perform well and that there’s a worthy winner in the end.
Most of all, I don’t want us to be having to debate whether a particular law is fit for purpose or if Raynal was right or wrong in deciding something that determined the outcome.
I’ll give you one law to ponder, before I go.
In rugby league, a deliberate knock down is merely a knock on. The defender doesn’t have to try and intercept the ball, he doesn’t have to prove his palm was pointing upwards and that he was trying to effect a catch.
The whistle simply blows, a scrum is packed and the game carries on.
I’d take that over 25 replays from various angles that result in someone being sent to the sinbin.
Latest Comments
As an artist, I’ve always been focused on my creative pursuits and never really ventured into the world of high-risk financial investments. But, like many others, I was drawn to the idea of making money quickly through Forex trading. Unfortunately, I fell victim to a Forex scam and lost a large portion of my savings. The financial loss was devastating, but the emotional toll was even worse. I felt betrayed, and hopeless, and wasn’t sure where to turn next. One day, while browsing through Red Note, a platform where people connect over shared experiences, I came across a post from someone who had gone through a similar situation. They shared how they managed to recover their lost funds through a company called Tech Cyber Force Recovery. Desperate for a solution, I decided to reach out to them and explain what had happened to me. I was initially skeptical, unsure whether this was just another scam or if it could be the real deal. To my surprise, the team at Tech Cyber Force Recovery was professional, compassionate, and genuinely interested in helping. They listened carefully to my story and assured me that they had the expertise and resources to help recover my lost funds. The process would take time, they said, and I’d need to provide some documentation, but they were confident that they could help. After several conversations and a thorough investigation, they started working on my case. The results were incredible. Within a relatively short period, Tech Cyber Force Recovery managed to recover nearly all of the funds I had lost. It wasn’t an easy process, and it required patience, but the team’s dedication, attention to detail, and methodical approach paid off. I felt an overwhelming sense of relief and gratitude. What had once seemed like a permanent loss was now being reversed, thanks to the help of Tech Cyber Force Recovery. Not only did the recovery restore my financial situation, but it also restored my sense of trust and confidence. I had almost given up hope, but now, with my funds recovered, I feel like I can move forward. I’ve learned valuable lessons from this experience, and I’m more cautious about my financial decisions in the future. What began as a desperate search on Red Note turned into a life-changing recovery. Thanks to Tech Cyber Force Recovery, I now feel more hopeful about my financial future, with the knowledge that recovery is possible.telegram (@)techcyberforc texts (+1 5.6.1.7.2.6.3.6.9.7)
Go to commentsJust too short to be an international 7.
Go to comments